Anguyo v Uganda (Criminal Appeal No. 38 of 2014) [2021] UGCA 3 (25 February 2021)

{\rtf1\ansi\ansicpg1252\uc1\deflang1033\adeflang1033\deflangfe1033\deff4\stshfloch4\stshfhich4\stshfbi4\stshfdbch4 {\fonttbl {\f0\fswiss\fcharset0 Tahoma;} {\f1\fswiss\fcharset0 Arial;} {\f2\fswiss\fcharset0 Calibri;} {\f3\froman\fcharset0 Times New Roman;} {\f4\fnil\fcharset0 Courier New;} } {\colortbl ; \red0\green0\blue0 ; \red0\green0\blue255 ; \red0\green255\blue255 ; \red0\green255\blue0 ; \red255\green0\blue255 ; \red255\green0\blue0 ; \red255\green255\blue0 ; \red255\green255\blue255 ; \red0\green0\blue128 ; \red0\green128\blue128 ; \red0\green128\blue0 ; \red128\green0\blue128 ; \red128\green0\blue0 ; \red128\green128\blue0 ; \red128\green128\blue128 ; \red192\green192\blue192 ; } {\*\defchp\fs24\afs24\loch\af4\hich\af4\dbch\af4} {\*\defpap\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\li0\ri0\ltrpar\ql\fi0\sb0\sa0\sl240\slmult1} {\stylesheet {\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\li0\ri0\ltrpar\ql\fi0\sb0\sa0\sl240\slmult1\lang1033\langfe1033\f4\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100 \dn0\fs24\afs24 Normal;} {\*\cs10\additive Default Paragraph Font;} {\*\cs15\additive\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0\sbasedon10\slink28 Body text_;} {\*\cs17\additive\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0\sbasedon10\slink29 Heading #1_;} {\*\cs18\additive\f1\b0\i0\scaps\strike0\fs28\afs28\ul0\sbasedon10\slink30 Body text (4)_;} {\*\cs19\additive\f1\b0\i\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0\sbasedon10\slink31 Body text (3)_;} {\*\cs22\additive\f3\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs20\afs20\ul0\sbasedon10\slink32 Header or footer (2)_;} {\*\cs24\additive\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0\sbasedon10\slink33 Body text (2)_;} {\*\cs27\additive\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0\sbasedon10\slink34 Picture caption_;} {\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\sa120\sl290\slmult1\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0\sbasedon0\slink15\sqformat Body text;} {\s29\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\sa120\sl281\slmult1\outlinelevel0\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0\sbasedon0\slink17 Heading #1;} {\s30\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\sa120\f1\b0\i0\scaps\strike0\fs28\afs28\ul0\sbasedon0\slink18 Body text (4);} {\s31\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\sl348\slmult1\f1\b0\i\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0\sbasedon0\slink19 Body text (3);} {\s32\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f3\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs20\afs20\ul0\sbasedon0\slink22 Header or footer (2);} {\s33\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\li810\fi10\sa120\sl293\slmult1\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0\sbasedon0\slink24 Body text (2);} {\s34\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0\sbasedon0\slink27 Picture caption;} } {\*\listtable {\list\listtemplateid0 {\listlevel\levelnfc0\levelnfcn0\leveljc0\leveljcn0\levelfollow0\levelstartat2\lang1033\langfe1033\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100 \dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0\levelspace0\levelindent0 {\leveltext\leveltemplateid1000001 \'02\'00.;} {\levelnumbers \'01;} } {\listlevel\levelnfc0\levelnfcn0\leveljc0\leveljcn0\levelfollow0\levelstartat2\lang1033\langfe1033\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100 \dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0\levelspace0\levelindent0 {\leveltext\leveltemplateid1000002 \'02\'00.;} {\levelnumbers \'01;} } {\listlevel\levelnfc0\levelnfcn0\leveljc0\leveljcn0\levelfollow0\levelstartat2\lang1033\langfe1033\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100 \dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0\levelspace0\levelindent0 {\leveltext\leveltemplateid1000003 \'02\'00.;} {\levelnumbers \'01;} } {\listlevel\levelnfc0\levelnfcn0\leveljc0\leveljcn0\levelfollow0\levelstartat2\lang1033\langfe1033\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100 \dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0\levelspace0\levelindent0 {\leveltext\leveltemplateid1000004 \'02\'00.;} {\levelnumbers \'01;} } {\listlevel\levelnfc0\levelnfcn0\leveljc0\leveljcn0\levelfollow0\levelstartat2\lang1033\langfe1033\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100 \dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0\levelspace0\levelindent0 {\leveltext\leveltemplateid1000005 \'02\'00.;} {\levelnumbers \'01;} } {\listlevel\levelnfc0\levelnfcn0\leveljc0\leveljcn0\levelfollow0\levelstartat2\lang1033\langfe1033\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100 \dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0\levelspace0\levelindent0 {\leveltext\leveltemplateid1000006 \'02\'00.;} {\levelnumbers \'01;} } {\listlevel\levelnfc0\levelnfcn0\leveljc0\leveljcn0\levelfollow0\levelstartat2\lang1033\langfe1033\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100 \dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0\levelspace0\levelindent0 {\leveltext\leveltemplateid1000007 \'02\'00.;} {\levelnumbers \'01;} } {\listlevel\levelnfc0\levelnfcn0\leveljc0\leveljcn0\levelfollow0\levelstartat2\lang1033\langfe1033\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100 \dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0\levelspace0\levelindent0 {\leveltext\leveltemplateid1000008 \'02\'00.;} {\levelnumbers \'01;} } {\listlevel\levelnfc0\levelnfcn0\leveljc0\leveljcn0\levelfollow0\levelstartat2\lang1033\langfe1033\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100 \dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0\levelspace0\levelindent0 {\leveltext\leveltemplateid1000009 \'02\'00.;} {\levelnumbers \'01;} } {\listname ;} \listid1} } {\*\listoverridetable {\listoverride\listid1\listoverridecount0\ls1} } {\info {\title} {\subject} {\author} {\keywords} } \paperw11900\paperh16840\margl1202\margr1400\margt2109\margb2023\gutter0\viewkind1\viewzk1\fet2\facingp\splytwnine\ftnlytwnine\htmautsp \useltbaln\alntblind\lytcalctblwd\lyttblrtgr\lnbrkrule\nobrkwrptbl\snaptogridincell\allowfieldendsel\wrppunct\asianbrkrule\newtblstyruls \nogrowautofit\usenormstyforlist\noindnmbrts\felnbrelev\nocxsptable\indrlsweleven\noafcnsttbl\afelev\utinl\hwelev\spltpgpar\notcvasp\notvatxbx \krnprsnet\cachedcolbal\noxlattoyen\noultrlspc\dntblnsbdb\nospaceforul\nolnhtadjtbl\notbrkcnstfrctbl\dgmargin\dghspace181\dgvspace181\dghshow1 \dgvshow1\sectd\ltrsect\pgnrestart\pgnstarts1\headery0\footery3\colsx720\sectlinegrid360\sftnbj\sftnrstcont {\footerr \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft5786\shptop15792\shpright5978\shpbottom15941\shpfhdr1\shpbxpage\shpbypage\shpwr3\shpwrk0 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} \shpz0 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 202}} {\sp{\sn dxTextLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextTop}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxTextRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextBottom}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn WrapText}{\sv 2}} {\sp{\sn fFitShapeToText}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fFilled}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLine}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\shptxt \pard\plain\wrapdefault\s32\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f3\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0 {\field {\*\fldinst PAGE \\* MERGEFORMAT } {\fldrslt {\cs22\lang1033\langfe1033\f2\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 #} } } \par } } } \par } {\footerl \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft5786\shptop15792\shpright5978\shpbottom15941\shpfhdr1\shpbxpage\shpbypage\shpwr3\shpwrk0 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} \shpz1 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 202}} {\sp{\sn dxTextLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextTop}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxTextRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextBottom}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn WrapText}{\sv 2}} {\sp{\sn fFitShapeToText}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fFilled}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLine}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\shptxt \pard\plain\wrapdefault\s32\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f3\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0 {\field {\*\fldinst PAGE \\* MERGEFORMAT } {\fldrslt {\cs22\lang1033\langfe1033\f2\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 #} } } \par } } } \par } {\footerf \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid \par } \titlepg \pard\plain\qc\sa120\sl293\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 THE REPUBLIC OF UGANDA\line IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF UGANDA AT LIRA\line CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 0038 OF 2014} \par \pard\plain\li4100\keep\keepn\fi-4100\sl360\slmult1\outlinelevel0\wrapdefault\s29\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0 \strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\*\bkmkstart bookmark0} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark1} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark2} {\cs17\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 ANGUYO SILIVA::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ::::::::::::::::::::APPELLANT VERSUS} {\*\bkmkend bookmark0} {\*\bkmkend bookmark1} {\*\bkmkend bookmark2} \par \pard\plain\sa120\wrapdefault\s30\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f1\b0\i0\scaps\strike0\fs28\afs28\ul0 {\cs18\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs28\afs28\ul0 UGANDA:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ::::::::;:::::::::} {\cs18\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs28\afs28\ul0\sub :} {\cs18\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs28\afs28\ul0 ::} {\cs18\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs28\afs28\ul0\sub ;} {\cs18\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs28\afs28\ul0 :resP0NDENT} \par \pard\plain\qj\sl348\slmult1\wrapdefault\s31\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f1\b0\i\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs19\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 (Appeal from the decision of the High Court of Uganda at Arua before Okwanga, J. delivered on the 22} {\cs19\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0\super nd} {\cs19\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 day of January, 2014 in Criminal Session Case No. 0051 of 2012.) } {\cs19\lang1033\langfe1033\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 CORAM: HON. LADY JUSTICE ELIZABETH MUSOKE, JA.} \par \pard\plain\li1400\fi40\sa120\sl302\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26 \ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 HON. LADY JUSTICE HELLEN OBURA, JA. HON. MR. JUSTICE REMMY KASULE, AG. JA.} \par \pard\plain\qc\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul JUDGMENT OF THE COURT} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Background} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 By a decision of the High Court (Okwanga, J.) passed on 21} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0\super st} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 January, 2014 the appellant herein was convicted of the offence of Aggravated Defilement contrary to } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Section 129 (3), (4) (a) and (b) } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 of the } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Penal Code Act, Cap. 120. } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 On. 22} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0\super nd} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 January, 2014, the High Court imposed on the appellant a sentence of 27 years imprisonment upon that conviction.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 The facts are that in the trial Court, the appellant had pleaded not guilty and was tried on an indictment which alleged that between the year of 2009 and 2010, he had, at Alia Village in the Arua District had unlawful sexual intercourse with A. S. A (the victim), a girl under the age of 14 years yet the appellant was infected with HIV/AIDS. According to the report from the medical examination of the victim (Exhibit PEI), at the material time, the victim was aged 7 years old.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 The prosecution evidence was that the victim's mother (PW3) and the appellant cohabited in the same home from about 2008 to 2011. While testifying at the trial, the victim stated that the appellant had forced her into sexual intercourse at the said home on three separate occasions. On each occasion, the appellant had waited for her mother to leave home. After the\page } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 sexual acts on each occasion, the appellant had threatened to kill the victim if she revealed the incidents to anyone else. Therefore, although she felt pain on each occasion, the victim said that she did not report the incidents to her mother for a long time between 2009 and 2011 due to the threats from the appellant.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 In 2011, when the appellant chased her mother from their home, the victim decided to speak out and inform her mother of the sexual acts committed on her by the appellant. The mother in turn reported the matter to the area local authorities. The appellant was subsequently arrested and charged in connection with the offence.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 At the trial, the appellant denied the offence. He said that he had been framed by the victim's mother for two reasons; firstly, because he opted to call off the cohabitation with the victim's mother and secondly, because he had refused to pay dowry for the victim's mother so as to legalize their marriage although the victim's mother had asked him to do so.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 At the conclusion of the trial, the learned trial Judge believed the prosecution evidence and convicted and sentenced the appellant as stated earlier. The appellant now appeals against the learned trial Judge's decision on the following grounds:} \par \pard\plain\li1420\qj\fi-700\sa100\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s33\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22 \ul0 {\cs24\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 "1. That the learned trial Judge ignored the discrepancies and inconsistency in the prosecution evidence on record thus occasioning a miscarriage of justice.} \par \pard\plain\tx1412\li1420\qj\fi-560\sa100\sl262\slmult1\wrapdefault\s33\f0 {\listtext\pard\plain 2.\'09\tab} \ls1\ilvl0\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0 {\*\bkmkstart bookmark3} {\*\bkmkend bookmark3} {\cs24\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 The learned trial Judge erred in law and fact when he convicted and sentenced the appellant on the uncorroborated evidence of the prosecution thus occasioning a miscarriage of justice.} \par \pard\plain\tx1412\li1420\qj\fi-560\sa100\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s33\f0 {\listtext\pard\plain 3.\'09\tab} \ls1\ilvl0\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0 {\*\bkmkstart bookmark4} {\*\bkmkend bookmark4} {\cs24\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 That the sentence was manifestly harsh and excessive in the circumstances."} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl271\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft7459\shptop1380\shpright9024\shpbottom2388\shpfhdr0\shpbxmargin\shpbypara\shpwr2\shpwrk1 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} \shpz2 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 75}} {\sp {\sn pib} {\sv {\pict\pngblip\picwgoal1565\pichgoal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} } } {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 114300}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 114300}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fAllowOverlap}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} } } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 The appellant prays that this Court allows the appeal and quashes his conviction by the trial Court or in the alternative, if the conviction is upheld, this Court finds it appropriate to impose a more lenient sentence than the one imposed by the learned trial Judge.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 The respondent opposed the appeal.} \sect \sectd\ltrsect\marglsxn1249\margrsxn1363\margtsxn1318\margbsxn1144\headery0\footery3\colsx720\sectlinegrid360\sftnbj\sftnrstcont {\footerr \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft5786\shptop15792\shpright5978\shpbottom15941\shpfhdr1\shpbxpage\shpbypage\shpwr3\shpwrk0 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} \shpz2 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 202}} {\sp{\sn dxTextLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextTop}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxTextRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextBottom}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn WrapText}{\sv 2}} {\sp{\sn fFitShapeToText}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fFilled}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLine}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\shptxt \pard\plain\wrapdefault\s32\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f3\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0 {\field {\*\fldinst PAGE \\* MERGEFORMAT } {\fldrslt {\cs22\lang1033\langfe1033\f2\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 #} } } \par } } } \par } {\footerl \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid \par } \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Representation} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 At the hearing, Mr. Odongo Daniel, learned counsel appeared for the appellant on State Brief. Ms. Joanita Tumwikirize, learned State Attorney in the office of the Director of Public Prosecutions appeared for the respondent. Due to the existing Covid-19 pandemic and the restrictions put in place by the Government to reduce the spread of the Covid-19 disease, including restrictions on movement of inmates from Government Prisons, the appellant could not be brought to Court from Lira Prison so as to be physically present at the hearing. However, the appellant participated in the hearing while in the prison with the aid of Zoom video conferencing technology.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Counsel for both sides addressed Court by way of written submissions after leave was granted for that purpose. The written submissions have been considered in this judgment.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Appellant's submissions} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Ground 1} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Counsel contended that the learned trial Judge did not address himself to the material discrepancies in the prosecution evidence before relying on it in reaching the decision to convict the appellant, something which occasioned a miscarriage of justice. Counsel submitted that there were material inconsistences in the prosecution evidence in respect to when the appellant allegedly defiled the victim. For instance, the indictment indicated that the victim was defiled between 2009 to 2010, while Exhibit PEI, the report from the medical examination of the victim made on 25} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0\super th} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 January, 2011 indicated that the victim was also defiled on or about 22} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0\super nd} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 January, 2011.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa40\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Counsel further submitted that the prosecution case was that the victim had been defiled between 2009 to 2010 but she had not reported the matter due to the appellant's alleged threats to harm her if she did so, until about 2011 when the appellant who was cohabiting with the victim's mother chased the latter from his home. PW3 Polina Ezaru, the victim's mother had stated in evidence that her daughter reported the acts of defilement against the appellant on or about 2} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0\super nd} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 January, 2011. There was no further prosecution evidence that the appellant had defiled the victim between 2} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0\super nd} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 January, 2011 and 25} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0\super th} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 January, 2011 when the victim's medical examination was done. In} \par \pard\plain\qc\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\fs0\afs0 { {\pict\pngblip\picwgoal1920\pichgoal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} } \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 counsel's view, the fact that the Exhibit PEI indicated that the victim had been defiled on about 22} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0\super nd} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 January, 2011 cast doubt on the prosecution evidence that the victim had been defiled between 2009 and 2010, which doubt should have been resolved in favour of the appellant. Counsel argued that the fact that the offence took place in 2010, and not in 2011 as Exhibit PEI indicated, lends credence to the appellant's defence evidence at the trial to the effect that the in making the allegations against him, the victim was motivated by the desire to tell lies about the appellant who had divorced her mother. Counsel contended that the victim's report may not have been made at all if the appellant had not called off the cohabitation with the victim's mother. Counsel further submitted that the fact that the victim testified that she reported the incident only after the appellant called off the cohabitation with her mother establishes that she was lying to court in order to punish the appellant for divorcing her mother.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sl360\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 In conclusion, counsel prayed that this Court allows ground 1 of the appeal. } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Ground 2} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa60\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Submitting on this ground, counsel for the appellant repeated his submissions on ground 1, but added that in his view, the victim's evidence was unlikely to be true because it was improbable that a sexual act could be carried out on the victim, then aged 5 to 6 years, on 3 occasions between 2009 to 2010 and go unnoticed by her mother who used to live with her. Counsel contended that the prosecution evidence that sexual acts took place on the 3 occasions between 2009 to 2010 remained uncorroborated and therefore the learned trial Judge had erred to base the appellant's conviction on the said acts. Counsel cited the authority of } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Kasumba Joseph vs. Uganda [2007] 1 HCB 18 } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 where it was held that for a sexual offence, a trial Court may convict on the uncorroborated evidence of the complainant if she is considered to be truthful but the Court must warn itself and the assessors of the dangers of convicting on such uncorroborated evidence. Counsel contended that in the present case the victim's testimony was not corroborated at all which left inconsistencies in the said evidence. Counsel prayed that this Court allows ground 2 of the appeal, too.} \par \pard\plain\keep\keepn\sa160\outlinelevel0\wrapdefault\s29\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\*\bkmkstart bookmark5} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark6} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark7} {\cs17\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Ground 3} {\*\bkmkend bookmark5} {\*\bkmkend bookmark6} {\*\bkmkend bookmark7} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Counsel submitted that although the offence of Aggravated Defilement of which the appellant was convicted is a serious offence with the maximum sentence being death sentence, the sentence of 27 years imprisonment imposed on the appellant is harsh and excessive in the circumstances. Counsel did not substantiate any further on this ground. However, he asked this Court to substitute a reduced sentence than the one imposed by the learned trial Judge.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Respondent's submissions} \par \pard\plain\qj\keep\keepn\sa100\sl276\slmult1\outlinelevel0\wrapdefault\s29\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0 \fs26\afs26\ul0 {\*\bkmkstart bookmark10} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark8} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark9} {\cs17\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Grounds 1 and 2} {\*\bkmkend bookmark10} {\*\bkmkend bookmark8} {\*\bkmkend bookmark9} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Counsel for the respondent argued grounds 1 and 2 of the appeal together, and supported the decision of the learned trial Judge to convict the appellant. Counsel contended that there was no miscarriage of justice contrary to the appellant's assertions. The appellant had on several occasions sexually abused the victim but the latter had not reported the abuse because the appellant had threatened to harm her if she did so. Counsel contended that the delay in reporting the abuse was the victim's way of holding some leverage over the appellant to prevent him from carrying out domestic violence on his mother.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Counsel further contended that contrary to the appellant's submissions, there was corroboration of the victim's evidence. Counsel submitted that PW3, the victim's mother had testified about the "signs" she ignored, which showed that the appellant was sexually abusing the victim. PW3 stated that in about 2010, she had seen the victim walking with some difficulty "with scattered legs". The victim's mother also testified that in the relevant period, the appellant used to ask to bathe the victim. Counsel further contended that further corroboration was in the appellant's conduct after the victim reported the incident, in that he attempted to escape from the village only to be arrested. Citing the authorities of } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Kyalimpa Apollo vs. Uganda, Court of Appeal Criminal Appeal No. 560 of 2014; } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 and } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 R vs. Kipkering Arap Osike and Another (1949) 16 EACA 135 } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 where the principles on circumstantial evidence were articulated, counsel submitted that the } \sect \sectd\ltrsect\marglsxn1249\margrsxn1363\margtsxn1318\margbsxn1144\sbknone\headery890\footery3\colsx720\sectlinegrid360\sftnbj\sftnrstcont {\footerr \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft5786\shptop15792\shpright5978\shpbottom15941\shpfhdr1\shpbxpage\shpbypage\shpwr3\shpwrk0 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} \shpz3 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 202}} {\sp{\sn dxTextLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextTop}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxTextRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextBottom}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn WrapText}{\sv 2}} {\sp{\sn fFitShapeToText}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fFilled}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLine}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\shptxt \pard\plain\wrapdefault\s32\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f3\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0 {\field {\*\fldinst PAGE \\* MERGEFORMAT } {\fldrslt {\cs22\lang1033\langfe1033\f2\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 #} } } \par } } } \par } {\footerl \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft5786\shptop15792\shpright5978\shpbottom15941\shpfhdr1\shpbxpage\shpbypage\shpwr3\shpwrk0 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} \shpz4 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 202}} {\sp{\sn dxTextLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextTop}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxTextRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextBottom}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn WrapText}{\sv 2}} {\sp{\sn fFitShapeToText}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fFilled}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLine}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\shptxt \pard\plain\wrapdefault\s32\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f3\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0 {\field {\*\fldinst PAGE \\* MERGEFORMAT } {\fldrslt {\cs22\lang1033\langfe1033\f2\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 #} } } \par } } } \par } \pard\plain\qj\fi0\sa120\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 appellant's stated conduct amounted to circumstantial evidence pointing to his guilt.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl276\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Counsel further contended that the victim had been consistent with her testimony that the appellant had defiled her, and had not been shaken in cross examination. The appellant, who was her step-father was well-known to the victim. In the circumstances, counsel urged this Court to find, in accordance with the principles articulated in } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Sarapio Tinkamalirwe vs. Uganda, Supreme Court Criminal Appeal No, 27 of 1989 } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 that any inconsistencies in the prosecution evidence were minor and did not affect the evidence.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl271\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 In conclusion, counsel submitted that all the circumstances of the case point to the guilt of the appellant and prayed that the Court disallows ground 1 and 2 of the appeal.} \par \pard\plain\qj\keep\keepn\sa120\sl271\slmult1\outlinelevel0\wrapdefault\s29\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0 \fs26\afs26\ul0 {\*\bkmkstart bookmark11} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark12} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark13} {\cs17\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Ground 3.} {\*\bkmkend bookmark11} {\*\bkmkend bookmark12} {\*\bkmkend bookmark13} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl271\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Counsel submitted that the sentence imposed on the appellant was neither harsh nor excessive considering the circumstances of the case. The appellant had sexually abused a child at a very tender age of 7 years, yet he was HIV positive. To aggravate matters, the appellant was a step-father to the victim and in a position of trust as a guardian with her.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl271\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Counsel further submitted that under the Sentencing Guidelines, the maximum sentence for the offence of aggravated defilement is death sentence, and the starting point for sentencing is set at 35 years. Thus, the sentence of 27 years which the trial Court imposed on the appellant was lesser than the said starting point, and that the same was neither harsh nor excessive. Counsel cited the authority of } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Kiwalabye Benard vs. Uganda, Supreme Court Criminal Appeal No. 143 of 2003, } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 where the reasons justifying an appellate Court to interfere with the sentence of the trial Court were laid down and prayed that this Court finds no such reasons in the present case.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl271\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Resolution of the Appeal.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl286\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 We have carefully studied the Court record, considered the submissions for either side, and the law and authorities cited therein; as well as those not cited but applicable to the present case.} \sect \sectd\ltrsect\marglsxn1181\margrsxn193\margtsxn2030\margbsxn2030\headery1602\footery3\colsx720\sectlinegrid360\sftnbj\sftnrstcont \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 A first appeal from the decision of the High Court to this Court requires this Court to review the evidence and make its own inferences of law and fact. } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 See: Rule 30 (1) (a) of the Judicature (Court of Appeal Rules) Directions S. I 13-10. } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 On a first appeal, this Court has a duty to "review the evidence of the case and to reconsider the materials before the trial judge. The appellate Court must then make up its own mind not disregarding the judgment appealed from but carefully weighing and considering it." } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 See: Kifamunte Henry vs. Uganda, Supreme Court Criminal Appeal No. 10 of 1997. } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Alive to the above-stated duty, we shall proceed to resolve the grounds of appeal as below.} \par \pard\plain\qj\keep\keepn\sa120\sl290\slmult1\outlinelevel0\wrapdefault\s29\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0 \fs26\afs26\ul0 {\*\bkmkstart bookmark14} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark15} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark16} {\cs17\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Grounds 1 and 2.} {\*\bkmkend bookmark14} {\*\bkmkend bookmark15} {\*\bkmkend bookmark16} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 The analysis on grounds 1 and 2 of the appeal will overlap and we find it convenient to deal with them together. The contention for the appellant is that the prosecution evidence which was relied on by the learned trial Judge in convicting the appellant contained material contradictions/ inconsistencies and should not have been relied on by the trial Court in convicting the appellant. It is also contended that there was a requirement for corroboration of the victim's evidence before it could be relied on.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl288\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 The law on the effect of contradictions/i nconsistencies in the prosecution evidence was articulated in the authority of } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Obwalatum Francis vs. Uganda, Criminal Appeal No. 30 of 2015, } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 where the Supreme Court held that:} \par \pard\plain\li680\qj\fi20\sa120\sl295\slmult1\wrapdefault\s33\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22 \ul0 {\cs24\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 "The Law on inconsistency is to the effect that where there are contradictions and discrepancies between prosecution witnesses which are minor and of a trivial nature, these may be ignored unless they point to deliberate untruthfulness. However, where contradictions and discrepancies are grave, this would ordinarily lead to the rejection of such testimony unless satisfactorily explained."} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl286\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 In } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 R vs. A. M, 2014 ONCA 769, } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 the Ontario Court of Appeal in Canada, commenting on the significance of inconsistencies in evidence stated:} \par \pard\plain\li680\qj\fi20\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s33\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22 \ul0 {\cs24\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 "... Inconsistencies vary in their nature and importance. Some are minor, others are not. Some concern material issues, others peripheral} \sect \sectd\ltrsect\marglsxn1126\margrsxn248\margtsxn2054\margbsxn560\headery1626\footery132\colsx720\sectlinegrid360\sftnbj\sftnrstcont {\footerr \pard\plain\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid \par } {\footerl \pard\plain\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid \par } \pard\plain\li780\qj\sa120\sl293\slmult1\wrapdefault\s33\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0 {\cs24\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 subjects. Where an inconsistency involves something material about which an honest witness is unlikely to be mistaken, the inconsistency may demonstrate a carelessness with the truth about which the trier of fact should be concerned."} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 With the above principles in mind, we shall consider the alleged inconsistencies in the prosecution evidence referred to by counsel for the appellant. Counsel pointed out that the indictment alleged that the sexual acts by the appellant on the victim were committed between 2009 and 2010; yet the victim's mother testified that the sexual acts also occurred in 2011. We have reviewed the evidence on this point. We observe that the victim in this case testified as PW4. The victim was familiar with the appellant, and knew him very well considering that the victim and the appellant lived together in the same house. The appellant was cohabiting with the victim's mother (PW3). Owing to the young age of the victim, she could not remember the exact dates when the appellant had committed each of the sexual acts on her. The victim testified, however, that the sexual acts by the appellant on three separate occasions happened at the house where they both lived.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 The first time, was when her mother had gone to "town"; and on that occasion, the victim stated at page 15 of the record that "the appellant caught me and threw me down and had sexual intercourse with me and warned me not to tell mother. He told me that if I reveal to mother he will kill me". The victim stated that on the second occasion, she had gone into the house to get drinking water, and the appellant entered the house, closed the door and had sex with her. The third time was when her mother had gone to Meridi.} \par \pard\plain\qj\sa100\sl382\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 The victim testified at page 16 of the record that after the third occasion, she had felt a lot of pain and complained to her mother about the pain. Her mother had taken her to an unidentified hospital for medical attention. The victim stated that at the hospital, they were issued with a medical form. However, when the appellant got to learn about the form, he tore it up and used it for smoking cigarettes. The victim testified at page 16 of the record, that she endured the sexual abuse until the appellant chased her mother b'S* } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 away from their home, when she decided to report the abuse to her mother. The victim's evidence was not shaken in cross-examination and was taken as truthful by the learned trial Judge.} \par \pard\plain\qj\fi140\sa100\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 We have also considered the evidence of PW3, the victim's mother. PW3's evidence at page 10 of the record, was that in November 2010, she noticed that the victim appearing to walk with some difficulty. PW3 stated that she was unable to find out the cause of the painful walking style, because the appellant prevented her from further questioning the victim. PW3 stated that from that time the appellant started bathing the victim. PW3 testified that during her cohabitation with the appellant, she endured several episodes of physical abuse. PW3 further stated that on 2} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0\super nd} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 March, 2011, when the appellant assaulted her, the victim broke her silence and reported the appellant's acts of defilement. We find that it is probable that the victim, may have endured the appellant's acts of defilement as a way of preventing him from assaulting her mother as he often had done. Thus we accept the respondent's submission to that effect.} \par \pard\plain\qj\fi140\sa100\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 It is true as pointed out by counsel for the appellant that at page 10 of the record, it is recorded that the victim's mother (PW3) stated in evidence that "I know why the accused (appellant) is now in court. Accused defiled my daughter S. A. It happened on 2/01/2011." But when taken in the context of the entirety of the prosecution evidence, this did not mean that the victim was only abused on that date. PW3 stated that it was on 2} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0\super nd} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 October, 2011 that the victim revealed the sexual abuse at the hands of the appellant to her. There were signs that the victim was subjected to sexual abuse earlier in 2010 when PW3 saw her walking with difficulty.} \par \pard\plain\qj\fi140\sa100\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 According to the report from the medical examination conducted on the victim on 25} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0\super th} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 January, 2011 (Exhibit PEI), there were signs on the victim's private parts such as a bruised labia minora and extensive hyperaemic lesions which indicated that there had been penetrative coitus (sexual intercourse) by use of force. We also observe that as contended by appellant's counsel, the report indicated that the victim's hymen had been ruptured about 72 hours earlier from when the report was made.} \sect \sectd\ltrsect\marglsxn1081\margrsxn292\margtsxn1983\margbsxn1793\headery0\footery3\colsx720\sectlinegrid360\sftnbj\sftnrstcont {\footerr \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft5872\shptop15147\shpright6069\shpbottom15296\shpfhdr1\shpbxpage\shpbypage\shpwr3\shpwrk0 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} \shpz5 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 202}} {\sp{\sn dxTextLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextTop}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxTextRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextBottom}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn WrapText}{\sv 2}} {\sp{\sn fFitShapeToText}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fFilled}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLine}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\shptxt \pard\plain\wrapdefault\s32\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f3\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0 {\field {\*\fldinst PAGE \\* MERGEFORMAT } {\fldrslt {\cs22\lang1033\langfe1033\f2\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 #} } } \par } } } \par } {\footerl \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft5786\shptop15792\shpright5978\shpbottom15941\shpfhdr1\shpbxpage\shpbypage\shpwr3\shpwrk0 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} \shpz6 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 202}} {\sp{\sn dxTextLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextTop}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxTextRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextBottom}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn WrapText}{\sv 2}} {\sp{\sn fFitShapeToText}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fFilled}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLine}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\shptxt \pard\plain\wrapdefault\s32\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f3\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0 {\field {\*\fldinst PAGE \\* MERGEFORMAT } {\fldrslt {\cs22\lang1033\langfe1033\f2\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 #} } } \par } } } \par } \pard\plain\qj\fi140\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 We} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 find from the overall evidence adduced, however, that this was a case of sexual abuse which happened to the victim on many occasions and over a significant period of time. We are satisfied that the victim knew the appellant, who lived with her for a longtime while he cohabited with the victim's mother. The cohabitation started in about 2008 and ended in November 2010. During this period the victim stayed with the appellant and her mother. This period is also satisfactorily covered in the indictment which alleged that the sexual acts committed on the victim took place between 2009 and 2010.} \par \pard\plain\qj\fi140\sa120\sl286\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 In the Supreme Court decision in } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Ntambala Fred vs. Uganda, Criminal Appeal No. 34 of 2015, } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 the Supreme Court held that:} \par \pard\plain\li840\qj\fi20\sa120\sl298\slmult1\wrapdefault\s33\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22 \ul0 {\cs24\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 "...a conviction can be solely based on the testimony of the victim as a single witness, provided the court finds her to be truthful and reliable. As stated by this Court in Sewanyana Livingstone vs. Uganda, SCCA No. 19 of 2006 "what matters is the quality and not quantity of evidence."} \par \pard\plain\qj\fi140\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 In the present case we are satisfied that the victim gave evidence which was truthful, credible and cogent about a person she had known so closely. We therefore find that there were no material contradictions in the prosecution evidence especially the evidence of the victim which requires us to reject that evidence. We also find that despite the lack of corroboration evidence, the victim's evidence alone, could be and was rightly relied on in the present case.} \par \pard\plain\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Grounds 1 and 2 are therefore, without merit and must fail.} \par \pard\plain\qj\keep\keepn\sa120\sl290\slmult1\outlinelevel0\wrapdefault\s29\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0 \fs26\afs26\ul0 {\*\bkmkstart bookmark17} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark18} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark19} {\cs17\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Ground 3.} {\*\bkmkend bookmark17} {\*\bkmkend bookmark18} {\*\bkmkend bookmark19} \par \pard\plain\qj\fi140\sa120\sl288\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 The appellant submitted, without substantiating that the sentence imposed by the learned trial Judge was harsh and excessive. Counsel for the respondent disagreed, and supported the sentence imposed by the learned trial Judge.} \par \pard\plain\qj\fi140\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 We note that counsel for the appellant never submitted that the learned trial Judge did not take into account any material factor in imposing the relevant sentence. Counsel only challenged the severity of the sentence. This, in our} \par \pard\plain\qc\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\fs0\afs0 { {\pict\pngblip\picwgoal768\pichgoal470 89504E470D0A1A0A0000000D494844520000005000000031010000000065C213FF0000000970485973000017120000171201679FD252000000884944415428916DCE210E C3301044D1B0421FC147F1D1AC2A203067AA0A0A73054701A581062B6F1774FF120F7AD248A359D4D31698602FF0A94E49B055B8AA732468BDD3FA3F25C3A67085B6EFEC 059E0A8F608612BC2B7C29DCE0C8502ABC155EC12D98E128D0078C5DE115FC04F760827EC62805F60AFD97F10CBE83DFE011DCA74C533E66FC01345ACDB869DC7AB60000 000049454E44AE426082 } } \par \pard\plain\li260\qj\fi20\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26 \ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 view, relates to the consistency principle to the effect that the sentences passed by the trial Court must as much as circumstances may permit, be similar to those passed in previously decided cases having a resemblance of facts as the one in which sentence is being passed; and the appellate Court, may if called upon to do so, be justified in interfering with the sentences which contravene this principle. } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 See: Aharikundira Yustina vs. Uganda, Supreme Court Criminal Appeal No. 27 of 2015.} \par \pard\plain\li260\qj\fi20\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26 \ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 We have therefore considered the sentences passed by this Court in previous aggravated defilement cases. In } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Ntambala Fred vs. Uganda, Criminal Appeal No. 34 of 2015, } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 the Supreme Court approved a sentence of 14 years imprisonment imposed on the appellant by the trial Court and confirmed by the Court of Appeal, considering it appropriate for aggravated defilement. The victim of the offence was aged 14 years.} \par \pard\plain\li260\qj\fi20\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26 \ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 In } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Byera Denis vs. Uganda, Court of Appeal Criminal Appeal No. 99 of 2012, } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 this Court substituted a sentence of 30 years imprisonment with one of 20 years imprisonment it considered appropriate in a case of aggravated defilement. The victim in that case was aged 3 years.} \par \pard\plain\li260\qj\fi20\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26 \ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 In } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Tiboruhanga Emmanuel vs. Uganda, Court of Appeal Criminal Appeal No. 0655 of 2014, } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 this Court stated that the sentences approved by this Court in previous aggravated defilement cases, without additional aggravating factors, range between 11 years to 15 years. The Court considered the fact that the appellant was HIV positive as an additional aggravating factor in that he had, by committing a sexual act on the victim while HIV positive, exposed her to the risk of contracting HIV/AIDS. The Court imposed a sentence of 25 years imprisonment.} \par \pard\plain\li260\qj\fi20\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26 \ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 In the present case, the sentence of 27 years is higher than the range of sentences imposed in the cases cited above. It is therefore harsh and excessive and we hereby set it aside. We proceed to determine a fresh sentence for the appellant pursuant to Section 11 of the Judicature Act, Cap. 13 which for the purposes of determining an appeal vests this Court with the powers of the trial Court; which powers include determining a fresh } {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 sentence, where the sentence of the trial Court is set aside for being harsh and excessive.} \par \pard\plain\qj\fi140\sa120\sl293\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 During the sentencing proceedings in the lower Court at page 34 of the record, the prosecution counsel submitted that the circumstances were aggravated by the fact that the appellant was convicted of a very serious offence for which the maximum penalty is the death sentence. Further, the victim of the offence was very young at only 7 years old and she stood in a position of being taken care of by the appellant who was her stepfather. In defiling the victim, the appellant violated the trust the victim had in him. Prosecution counsel submitted that the victim was left with psychological trauma which may affect her future. Counsel submitted that following the commission of the offence the appellant was examined and found to be HIV positive. Counsel also pointed out that the offence for which the appellant was convicted is rampant and there was need to impose a deterrent sentence.} \par \pard\plain\qj\fi140\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 In mitigation of the sentence at page 35 of the record, defence counsel submitted that the appellant was still a young man at only 32 years of age. The appellant had spent a period of about 3 years on remand while attending trial. The appellant was married and was a bread winner to his family. Counsel submitted that the appellant had a future and a long custodial sentence would not be helpful to him. Counsel submitted that the appellant was remorseful and he prayed for a lenient sentence.} \par \pard\plain\qj\fi140\sa120\sl290\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 We also note that the appellant was HIV positive as evidenced in Exhibit PE3, showing the results of an HIV test conducted on the appellant on 28 January, 2011. Thus, in the present case, considering all the relevant material, we find that a sentence of 25 years imprisonment is appropriate. From the testimony of the appellant, supported by the trial Court record, he was arrested on 23 January, 2011. Therefore, on 21} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0\super st} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 January, 2014 when he was convicted, the appellant had been on remand for 2 years, 11 months and 2 days. The remand period is deducted from the sentence we have imposed. The appellant shall therefore serve a sentence of 21 years and 28} \par \pard\plain\qc\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\fs0\afs0 { {\pict\pngblip\picwgoal797\pichgoal374 89504E470D0A1A0A0000000D49484452000000530000002701000000005B7A497A0000000970485973000017120000171201679FD2520000007B49444154189585CDB10D 84300C85E14814941921A3643474BA22253351B1066C001D05E201C7C5BF3B5C7DB2DEB383EA1C29988BCC5BC645E66B6D1E64DE135E3A5C64FE45FE9E851BBC473C65FC 118EF8B9F87811FE3AB7B8C66FD7F8EDC139E223E1ADC3ABF0E8DC63AA0A5415ECEBE5D97974EE9D93737EF709AED4949EF46A3AD70000000049454E44AE426082 } } \sect \sectd\ltrsect\marglsxn1081\margrsxn292\margtsxn1983\margbsxn1793\headery1555\footery3\colsx720\sectlinegrid360\sftnbj\sftnrstcont {\footerr \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft5786\shptop15792\shpright5978\shpbottom15941\shpfhdr1\shpbxpage\shpbypage\shpwr3\shpwrk0 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} \shpz7 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 202}} {\sp{\sn dxTextLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextTop}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxTextRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextBottom}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn WrapText}{\sv 2}} {\sp{\sn fFitShapeToText}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fFilled}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLine}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\shptxt \pard\plain\wrapdefault\s32\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f3\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0 {\field {\*\fldinst PAGE \\* MERGEFORMAT } {\fldrslt {\cs22\lang1033\langfe1033\f2\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 #} } } \par } } } \par } {\footerl \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft5786\shptop15792\shpright5978\shpbottom15941\shpfhdr1\shpbxpage\shpbypage\shpwr3\shpwrk0 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} \shpz8 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 202}} {\sp{\sn dxTextLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextTop}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxTextRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextBottom}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn WrapText}{\sv 2}} {\sp{\sn fFitShapeToText}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fFilled}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLine}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\shptxt \pard\plain\wrapdefault\s32\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f3\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs22\afs22\ul0 {\field {\*\fldinst PAGE \\* MERGEFORMAT } {\fldrslt {\cs22\lang1033\langfe1033\f2\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs22\afs22\ul0 #} } } \par } } } \par } \pard\plain\li140\fi20\sa120\sl283\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 days imprisonment to run from the date of his conviction on 21} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0\super st} {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 January, 2014. Ground 3 of the appeal therefore succeeds.} \par \pard\plain\li140\qj\fi20\sa120\sl288\slmult1\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26 \ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 In conclusion, this appeal is dismissed as to conviction for the reasons stated herein above and is partially allowed as to sentence on the terms herein set out.} \par \pard\plain\keep\keepn\fi140\sl288\slmult1\outlinelevel0\wrapdefault\s29\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0 \fs26\afs26\ul0 {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft1624\shptop2765\shpright3736\shpbottom4215\shpfhdr0\shpbxmargin\shpbymargin\shpwr3\shpwrk0 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} \shpz9 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 75}} {\sp {\sn pib} {\sv {\pict\pngblip\picwgoal2112\pichgoal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} } } {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fAllowOverlap}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} } } {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft313\shptop7378\shpright4652\shpbottom8578\shpfhdr0\shpbxmargin\shpbymargin\shpwr3\shpwrk0 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} \shpz10 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 75}} {\sp {\sn pib} {\sv {\pict\pngblip\picwgoal4339\pichgoal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} } } {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fAllowOverlap}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} } } {\*\bkmkstart bookmark20} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark21} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark22} {\cs17\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 We so order.} {\*\bkmkend bookmark20} {\*\bkmkend bookmark21} {\*\bkmkend bookmark22} \sect \sectd\ltrsect\marglsxn1154\margrsxn219\margtsxn2209\margbsxn1634\sbknone\headery0\footery3\colsx720\sectlinegrid360\sftnbj\sftnrstcont \pard\plain\pvpara\phmrg\posx158\posy20\absh331\absw2122\overlay\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26 \afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Dated at Lira this} \par \pard\plain\pvpara\phmrg\posx4195\posy20\absh346\absw826\overlay\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26 \afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 day of} \par \pard\plain\sa364\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid \par \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid \sect \sectd\ltrsect\marglsxn0\margrsxn0\margtsxn2209\margbsxn5479\sbknone\headery0\footery3\colsx720\sectlinegrid360\sftnbj\sftnrstcont \pard\plain\sl-240\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\fs19\afs19 \par \pard\plain\sl-240\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\fs19\afs19 \par \pard\plain\sb62\sa62\sl-240\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\fs19\afs19 \par \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid \sect \sectd\ltrsect\marglsxn1265\margrsxn1367\margtsxn2209\margbsxn5479\sbknone\headery0\footery3\colsx720\sectlinegrid360\sftnbj\sftnrstcont \pard\plain\sl-1\slmult0\wrapdefault\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft620\shptop1123\shpright1743\shpbottom1814\shpfhdr0\shpbxmargin\shpbypara\shpwr1\shpwrk0 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} \shpz3 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 75}} {\sp {\sn pib} {\sv {\pict\pngblip\picwgoal1123\pichgoal691 89504E470D0A1A0A0000000D4948445200000075000000480100000000E09B87620000000970485973000017120000171201679FD252000001DB49444154388DA5D3318E D430140660AF1669CA888E02615151D3A375C9393802A2D96285575AA474445C6073118A5D4D612A7C84992812E9C84429C601AF7FDEB333CEEC48888234936F6C27FF7B 760430E2E812FFF6F49F7E38B13FDC8713FF3CF1F7E490AD93F5ECCF7FB1C20672F12F853AAC16FF56E8DD0DF9367B3F0D4796D80F6EF154631C3DDDBF58DC7995FD5061 E803BDF0227BB228B2115D2DB67016655E4FF605CC62032F41819E6707767893FA818EED16B7A0729DC6331DF4EC021458C83CFEC8F4A882BB746E6067BF65AFC6343E21 187E643165C757487FB0276F62A7D90E62E42A3856F44E0C9C92D7448BCB29B94A96FE92DC7365EC6F9ABDA7BB75F413EDAF38152727BB0BED3FEAE8817D1714BB21EFC8 4106E9B5C69794840BA5A0CAF331F4D40F8E4E1ED841F1F3517BD4361E5329A806DE8B5B359B377A0D7CD2D10557C2D1CB74ACAD68D2599B6D4417E90AB831DA46DFD770 69BC4ED337072BFEF16A83AFF17FDE133EF235E2C42ACDAF48F79CB710658C457634D34BD1C632A0A9AB8AD689D416FE067E88AB5710BB0FE3F8B4DBF67DD76FC5CA8ADD 59D3BE6E9BAE5DDBB5294B31DCBDDBBE6FD66493ECCE9BA1B9E9BACE74BD29A93FD72F876B1C2EFE1EC5198E0DAF1E3B7F80B3614F6C16FF0184FCAB13B5CC101B000000 0049454E44AE426082 } } } {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 486410}} {\sp{\sn dyWrapDistTop}{\sv 114300}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 190500}} {\sp{\sn dyWrapDistBottom}{\sv 323215}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fAllowOverlap}{\sv 1}} {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 1}} } } {\shp {\*\shpinst\shpleft34\shptop1992\shpright1858\shpbottom2323\shpfhdr0\shpbxmargin\shpbypara\shpwr3\shpwrk0 {\sp{\sn fBehindDocument}{\sv 0}} \shpz0 {\sp{\sn shapeType}{\sv 202}} {\sp{\sn dxTextLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextTop}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxTextRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dyTextBottom}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fFilled}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLine}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistLeft}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn dxWrapDistRight}{\sv 0}} {\sp{\sn fLayoutInCell}{\sv 1}} {\shptxt \pard\plain\wrapdefault\s34\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs27\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Hellen Obura} \par } } } \par \pard\plain\keep\keepn\sa180\outlinelevel0\wrapdefault\s29\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\*\bkmkstart bookmark23} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark24} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark25} {\cs17\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Elizabeth Musoke} {\*\bkmkend bookmark23} {\*\bkmkend bookmark24} {\*\bkmkend bookmark25} \par \pard\plain\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Justice of Appeal.} \par \pard\plain\sa1160\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Justice of Appeal.} \par \pard\plain\keep\keepn\sa180\outlinelevel0\wrapdefault\s29\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\*\bkmkstart bookmark26} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark27} {\*\bkmkstart bookmark28} {\cs17\lang1033\langfe1033\b\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Rem my Kasule} {\*\bkmkend bookmark26} {\*\bkmkend bookmark27} {\*\bkmkend bookmark28} \par \pard\plain\wrapdefault\s28\aspalpha\aspnum\faauto\adjustright\cgrid\f0\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\fs26\afs26\ul0 {\cs15\lang1033\langfe1033\b0\i0\scaps0\strike0\cf1\expndtw0\charscalex100\dn0\fs26\afs26\ul0 Ag. Justice of Appeal.} \par }