Lawrence Nduttu & 156 others v Kenya Breweries Ltd [2018] KEHC 8717 (KLR)

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA

AT NAIROBI

CIVIL CASE  NO. 279  OF 2003

LAWRENCE NDUTTU & 156 OTHERS..............................PLAINTIFFS

-V E R S U S –

KENYA BREWERIES LTD.................................................. DEFENDANT

JUDGEMENT

1) The plaintiffs, numbering 157 filed this representative suit on their behalf and on behalf of former employees of Kenya Breweries Ltd, the defendant herein, whose terms and conditions of employment were governed by a memorandum of agreement dated 5th December 1997 and 29th July 1999 and whose contract of employment were affected by the defendant’s re-engineering process which began in 1994.  The aforesaid action is by way of the Further Amended plaint dated 2/12/2015 where the plaintiffs sought for judgement as follows:

a)A declaration that decision to cause their early retirement was unlawful and breached Section 80 and 82 of the Constitution and was  wrongful and a nullity.

b)A declaration that the defendant’s action to cause early retirement of the plaintiffs was unlawful and unfair and amounted to breach of the plaintiffs, contracts of employment.

c)A declaration that the defendant’s calculation of the plaintiffs’ terminal benefits were wrong, arbitrary and they helped the defendant to withhold huge sums due to the plaintiffs.

d)An order that the defendant should pay all the plaintiffs all the outstanding dues and salaries until their retirement age at sixty years.

e)An order that the defendant do supply to the plaintiffs and each of them audited statement of account detailing their dues.

f)An order that the plaintiffs and each of them be paid all outstanding dues and other consequential entitlements pursuant to prayer (b) above.

g)AND or alternatively, general damages for loss of employment being 12 months salary for each and every plaintiff.

h) Costs of (b) and (c ) with interest covers at court rates.

2) The defendant on its part, filed a defence dated 8th May 2018, and amended on 12. 11. 2008 and further amended 6. 1.2016 in which it denied violating the plaintiffs’ constitutional or other rights.  The defendant also stated that the redundancies were declared in accordance with the applicable Labour and Employment laws.  The defendant further averred that the plaintiffs’ termination was lawful and that they were paid their dues.

3) When the suit came up for hearing, the plaintiffs summoned James Sibili (P.W.1), Michael Kimonyi (P.W.2) and Lawrence Kyalo Ndutu (P.W.3) to testify in support of their case.The defendant on the other hand summoned one Evans Kipngetich Mutai (D.W.1) to testify in support of its defence.

4)  It is the evidence of James Sibili (PW1) that he together with Michael Kimonyi (P.W.2) and Albanus Ngwiri were appointed to represent over 820 former employees of Kenya Breweries Ltd in this suit.  PW1 adopted the contents of his witness statement as his evidence in this suit.  He claimed that he together with his colleagues were unfairly sacked by the defendant in contravention of the law through a flawed process known as Early Retirement Scheme which begun in 1994.  PW1 further stated that the process for early retirement had conditionalities.  PW1 also stated that he did not opt for retirement but he was nevertheless issued with an early retirement letter on 15. 6.1998.  P.W.1 further stated that they were retired in breach of the memorandum of agreement between their union and the defendant.  Under the aforesaid agreement, the circumstances under which an employee can be retired and or sacked are specified.  P.W.1 further pointed out that under Clauses 25 and 27 of the memorandum of agreement, the employer was allowed to terminate an employee from employment if the employer is making losses by declaring such an employee  redundant.  The witness also stated that the defendant begun the process of what it called re-engineering without consulting them nor their union.  It was pointed out by PW1 that at no time did the defendant make losses, therefore it was not justified to force them into early retirement.  It is the evidence of P.W.1 that he proceeded for leave when he received the letter requiring him to take early retirement.  He said that when he came back from the forced leave he was issued with a letter showing him his exit package.  P.W.1 alleged that the package was prepared by the defendant without prior consultation.  He said that the decision to terminate his services took away his expectation to work until retirement.  He stated that he together with his colleagues were  not given a chance to explain themselves out before being declared redundant.  P.W.1 further alleged that the defendant employed new employees to replace those who were unlawfully forced to take early retirement and or declared redundant like him.  P.W.1 averred that he was claiming for a refund of ksh.50,000/=, an amount which was retained by the defendant when he was forced to leave the defendant’s employment.  P.W.1 also pointed that there was a schedule showing what was due to each employee as a refund.  In his evidence in cross –examination, P.W.1 stated that his contract of employment was based on the memorandum of agreement between their union and their employer, the defendant herein.  He also averred that whatever agreement reached between the union and the employer bound them.  P.W.1 conceded in cross-examination that they had no evidence that the defendant employed new employees after they were retired.  P.W.1 also stated that though he had alleged that the defendant discriminated him he had no evidence to prove the allegation levelled against the defendant.

5) Michael Kimonyi (P.W.2) adopted the contents of the witness statement he executed as his evidence.  He stated that he worked at the security section having been employed at the age of 24 years.  PW2 claimed that he was forced by the defendant to take up early retirement after working for only 9 years vide a letter dated 17. 8.1999.  He alleged that he has never been paid the money the defendant deducted and retained after he left employment.  P.W.2 claimed that there was no clause in the contract of employment which provides an early retirement.  He also alleged that the defendant employed new employees after retiring them.  PW2 stated in cross-examination that he was actually paid ksh.50,000/= but others were not paid.  PW2 re-affirmed in his evidence in  re-examination that there were no sufficient consultation before the implementation of the early retirement scheme.

6) Lawrence Kyalo Ndutu (P.W.3) also adopted the contents of his witness statement as his evidence in support of his claim and those plaintiffs whom he represented.  In cross-examination P.W.3 stated that there was a memorandum of agreement between the union and the defendant which gave rise to the joint Industrial Council where he was a member.  P.W.3 pointed out that the memorandum of agreement set out the amounts payable to him.  P.W.3 conceded that he was paid the amount specified.  P.W.3 also stated that the memorandum of agreement indicated that he was to receive computation from the financial accountant which he received but was not paid as was computed therein. P.W.3 was emphatic that the defendant has not paid all the amounts due the plaintiffs.

7)  In support of the defence case is the evidence of Evans Kipngetich Mutai (D.W.1) the defendant’s Human Resource Director.  D.W.1 adopted the contents of his witness statement as his evidence.  He stated that the memorandum of understanding between the defendant and the union was to determine the wages, hours of work and the conditions of employment of unionisable workers.  D.W.1 stated that in the year 1997 the defendant underwent a re-engineering process in which a radical review of business to cut costs and improve efficiency by automation.  This exercise, D.W. 1 said led to the closure of the defendant’s Mombasa and Kisumu plans.  D.W.1 stated the employees were allowed to opt for early retirement.  This witness denied the allegation that the plaintiffs were discriminated.  D.W.1 stated that there was an agreement between plaintiffs’’ union and the defendant that the defendant would retain ksh.100,000/= to cover debts and or liabilities due to the defendant or Tembo Cooperative.  In cross-examination, D.W.1 stated that the retirement age was set at 60 years.  He also stated that the defendant came up with the idea of Voluntary Early Retirement before attaining the age of 60 years.  DW1 stated that employees would write to the defendant requesting to take an early retirement.  It is the evidence of D.W.1 that the document used to operationalise the early retirement scheme had given the defendant the discretion to reject or accept such requests.  DW1 stated that the defendant reviewed its business and found that it had excess employees who needed to be of loaded having invested heavily in technology to improve efficiency.  He stated that the Unions were engaged to set up the terms of redundancies and the defendant settled for redundancy and abandoned the Voluntary Early Retirement Scheme.  D.W. 1 further stated that the defendant undertook what it called re-engineering to reduce costs of production and improve efficiency.

8) D.W. 1 claimed that there was a joint industrial council who met and agreed on Voluntary Early Retirement Scheme but he failed to tender in evidence the minutes of council meetings held.  D.W.1 also stated that part of the initial payments were retained by the defendant.  As for management employees, a sum of ksh.100,000/= was retained while a sum of kshs.50,000/= was retained in respect of unionisable staff.  In his evidence in re-examination, D.W1 stated that there was an early retirement package which was voluntary but the same was subsequently there was termination which was not voluntary.  D.W.1 denied that the calculations of the exit package were arbitrary.  He stated that the defendant used the Kenya Revenue Authority tax calculation guidelines to employers to tabulate what was due to the employees leaving.

9) At the close of evidence, parties were invited to file and exchange written submission.  Learned counsels appearing in the matter were also allowed to make oral highlights.  Having considered the evidence together with the rival submissions, the following issues commend themselves for the determination of this court.

i)Whether or not the early retirement scheme was carried out in contravention of the constitution and the existing contracts of employment.

ii)Whether or not the plaintiffs are entitled to a refund of the monies allegedly withheld by the defendant.

iii)Whether or not the plaintiffs are entitled to be paid their salaries upto the date of retirement.

iv)Whether or not the plaintiffs are entitled to general damages for loss of employment.

v)Whether or not the terminal benefits claimed by the plaintiffs are properly computed.

10) On the first issue, it is the submission of the plaintiffs that defendant developed a voluntary early retirement scheme in which any employee who desired early retirement had to fill a given form and present it for consideration by the management and there was no guarantee that the request would be accepted by the employer.  It was pointed out that some of the conditions which were to be fulfilled before an employee could be allowed to take up a voluntary early retirement included inter alia poor or low productivity, poor disciplinary record, poor health and that one should have attained the age of 50 years.  It is also the submission of the plaintiffs that employees who were aged above 50 years would earn his/her salary upto the retirement age of 60 years.  The plaintiffs have pointed out that the Voluntary Early Retirement Scheme did not achieve the desired results of getting many employees retire from their service.  It is further the submission of the plaintiffs that without consulting their union the defendant unilaterally crafted a scheme to send home a number of employees.  It is said that the defendant would send an employee on compulsory leave and upon his/her return, he/she would  be issued with a letter of early retirement, letter of service and a schedule of computation of his/her dues and thereafter the employee would  be asked to sign documents to clear and leave the company premises.  The plaintiffs referred to this latter scheme as Unilateral Forced Early Retirement Scheme.  In response to the plaintiffs’ submissions, the defendant argued that the plaintiffs’ union was consulted and made aware of the intended implementation of the voluntary early retirement scheme.  The defendant relied in evidence minutes of a meeting of the Joint Industrial Council held on 11. 08. 2000.  The defendant further stated that in implementing the early retirement scheme it did not discriminate against any employee.  The defendant further denied breaching Sections 80 and 82 of the 1963 constitution.  It also denied breaching the terms of the memorandum of understanding entered between it and the plaintiffs’ union.  I have carefully examined the minutes heavily relied upon by the defendant in respect of the meeting which took place on 11th August 2000.  It is apparent that the early retirement scheme took place between the year 1997 and 2001. The minutes relied upon are in respect of a meeting of  Joint Industrial Council meeting held on 11. 8.2000.  It is evident that the early retirement scheme was done more than three(3) years before the consultative meeting was held.  The defendant did not tender minutes of any meetings held between the defendant and the plaintiffs’’ union prior to the commencement of the forced early retirement scheme.  A critical examination of the minutes tendered by the defendant will show that the union had clearly stated that it had never been party to the forced early retirement scheme.  In fact, the union clearly stated that the defendant had turned the initial voluntary retirement scheme to forced early retirement.  After a careful evaluation of the evidence, I am convinced that the plaintiffs have shown that they were forced to take an early retirement without being consulted nor the participation of their union.  The initial scheme was voluntary but the same was later forced through the plaintiffs throats.  The documentary evidence presented by both sides show that the plaintiffs’ were employed by the defendant on permanent and pensionable terms and were each expected to retire at the age of 60 years. The plaintiffs have complained that their rights as enshrined under Sections 80 and 82 of the constitution (now repealed).  The defendant has argued that the plaintiffs have failed to tender evidence showing that they were discriminated in the implementation of the early retirement schemes.  It has emerged from the evidence tendered that though there was no open discrimination against the plaintiffs, it was not clear what criteria was applied in identifying those to take up early retirement.  In the absence of a clear explanation, this court is entitled to infer that there was subtle discrimination as against the plaintiffs vis-a-vis those who remained in employment.  The plaintiffs have also argued that their right to fair labour practices guaranteed under Article 41 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010 were breached.  In response to this submission, the defendant cited the case of Alfred Asidaga Mulima and 2 others =vs= Attorney General and 8 others, Nairobi C.A no. 179 of 2015in which the Court of Appeal held inter alia, that a court cannot enforce rights created under the new constitution unless those rights were recognised and protected under the previous constitution.  With respect, I agree with the defendant’s latest submission.  In the circumstances this court by inference finds that the plaintiffs’ right to protection from discrimination under Sections 80 and 82 of the Constitution of Kenya (now repealed) was breached.

11) The other question which is related to the above is whether the implementation of the early retirement scheme was in breach of the contract of employment between the plaintiffs and the defendant.  The plaintiffs have argued that the letters sending them home for early retirement cannot be treated as redundancies.  They are of the view that the same were unilateral forced early retirement scheme.

12) The defendant on the other hand is of the view that as unionisable employees, the plaintiffs’ terms of employment as per the  memorandum of understanding provided for a declaration of redundancies described as loss of employment through no fault of the employee concerned.  This court was urged to find that the early retirement scheme was redundancy as defined in the memorandum and the labour laws.  The plaintiffs are of the view that the defendant was not justified to declare redundancies because no losses were declared and that the re-engineering process served no other purpose but was meant to increase profitability.  The defendant was of the submission that as an employer it was permitted by law to declare a redundancy if the employer decides to reorganize its business to run more efficiently and profitably.

13) I have carefully perused the Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) executed between the defendant and the plaintiffs’ union, the Kenya Union of Commercial Food and Allied Workers (KUCFAW) and the contract of employment.  In the aforesaid documents, there is no mention of an early retirement scheme.  There is no doubt that the early retirement scheme was a creation of the defendant. It has already been stated that the scheme was meant to be voluntary in the initial states.  The plaintiff beseeched this court to treat the early retirement scheme as a form of redundancy.  It is not in dispute in the C.B.A and in the contract of employment redundancy is stated to be one of the methodology in which an employees’ employment could be brought to an end.  It is expressly stated that redundancy should be with clearly laid down procedures.  The C.B.A and the labour laws are very clear on what conditions must met for redundancy to be applied.  First, it must be justified and proven that there is need to reduce the number of employees in order to save the employer from collapse.  Secondly, that the redundancy process and package must be negotiated and explained in advance to the persons affected.  Thirdly, that there must be a clear criterion as to which employee  would exit and why must be laid down.  In this case the defendant failed to produce its annual statement of account to show its financial status despite having been served with a notice to produce by the plaintiffs.  The plaintiffs’ assertion that the defendant was then and has continued to-date on an upward profitability trend remains uncontroverted.  There is no evidence that the process was negotiated by the employees affected.  In the absence of the above mentioned features, it cannot be said the defendant’s early retirement scheme can be treated as redundancy.  With respect, I am convinced that the plaintiffs were justified to plead that the defendant’s scheme was left at the whims of sectional head and was inbured with extreme favourism and discrimination.  The plaintiffs were therefore right to claim discrimination since there were no guidelines to justify why they were retired while others of similar qualifications were left to continue to work. It is clear in my mind that the plaintiffs were removed from employment whimsically and without following the laid down labour laws and procedures.  Consequently, the plaintiffs’ termination and or dismissal is declared to be unlawful and therefore the plaintiffs are entitled to be compensated.

14) The second issue to be determined is whether or not the plaintiffs are entitled to be refunded monies withheld by the defendants.  It is the submission of the defendant that the plaintiffs are not entitled to be refunded the aforesaid sum because the plaintiffs failed to  specifically plead and prove save for the two plaintiffs who testified.  The defendant further argued that most of the plaintiffs were paid back the refund after it was established that they did not owe the company money.  The defendant also argued that the claim was not similar to each plaintiff.  The defendant further pointed out that the schedules of payments prepared by the learned advocates were never admitted as exhibits in evidence.  The defendant also argued that it has set up the defence which is to the effect that the claim for a refund is time-barred therefore the claim for ksh.20,775,152/= is not justified.  The plaintiffs have beseeched this court to order the defendant to refund the monies it withheld as security.  It is pointed out that the defendant has admitted having deducted the aforementioned amounts from the plaintiffs.  The plaintiffs have urged this court to order the defendant to pay the claim as per the schedules provided by two firms of advocates.  I have considered the evidence provided by both sides plus the submissions over this claim.  There is no doubt that this claim was pleaded in the plaint.  The plea may not have been precise due to the numerous number of plaintiffs.  It is not in dispute that three plaintiffs testified on behalf of the rest of the plaintiffs and this is not unusual in representative suits like in this case.  The defendant has stated that the claim is timebarred.  It is unfortunate that the defendant has failed to lay both the factual and legal basis of this ground but it has instead made a general submission which did not help its defence.  Both the plaintiffs and the defendant concur that the defendant retained from each employee either a sum of ksh.50,000/= or ksh.100,000/= as security for the defendant company liabilities.  The plaintiffs provided a full list of names and amounts of refunds due to each plaintiff.  I have already stated that defendant has stated that the amounts were repaid to the plaintiffs.  The defendant summoned its Human Resource Manager, (DW1), to testify in its defence.  Unfortunately, DW1 did not produce in evidence any documents or form of evidence to prove reimbursement or repayment of the amount withheld.  The plaintiffs produced in court in compliance with this court’s directive two lists of claimants and the pay off schedules to confirm the deductions.  The schedule filed by the firm of Namada and Co. Advocates dated 11th day of May 2016 shows that the defendant has withheld a sum of ksh.20,775,152 in respect of the plaintiffs whom the aforesaid firm represents. This document has guided this court to ascertain the amount withheld and not repaid by the defendant.  The defendant has not controverted the schedule.  It cannot therefore lie in its mouth to deny the same.  There is no reason why the plaintiffs should not be paid this claim.  Consequently the plaintiffs who are show in the schedule prepared by the firm of Namada & Co. Advocates dated 11. 05. 2016 should be paid a sum of ksh.20,775,144/= as shown in the aforesaid list as follows:

NAMADA & CO. ADVOCATES - SCHEDULE OF PAYMENT

NO. NAME DATE OF TERMINATION AMOUNT

PAID AMOUNT

TAXED

OFF AMOUNT WITHHELD

1. URBANUS NGWILI 02/12/1997

2. MICHAEL KIMUNYI 17/8/1999 175,226/= 66,830/= 100,000/=

3. JAMES SIBILI 15/6/1999 260,611/= 50,121/= 50,000/=

4. SOPHIA WAMBUI 18/02/1999 570,743/= 69,321/=

5. ZACHARIA KATEE 15/09/2001 1,051,722/= 145,144/= 50,000/=

6. REUBEN NOKATA 19/10/1998 661,578/= 95,667/=

7. JAMES NJOROGE 15/05/1998 370,291/= 65,717/= 15,000/=

8. JOHN NJENDU KIRUBI 25/04/2003 649,432/= 183,216/= 50,000/=

9. MICHAEL THINWA KIBUI 01/07/2000 318,104/= 58,573/= 50,000/=

10. PETER KAGIKA MUTURI 03/04/1998 688,238/= 92,522/= 100,000/=

11. ATHUMANI OMARI 31/12/1997 584,889/=

12. PAUL GATHUKU 15/05/1998 166,148/= 23,743/= 50,000/=

13.

14. MOHAMMED SAID ALI 18/06/1998 166,148/= 23,743/= 50,000/=

15. MATHIAS MUIA MWANTHI 17/08/1999 104,663/= 51,880/=

16. HELLEN MWELU JOSEPH 15/05/1998 61,702/= 7,205/=

17. TOM SILA MULUNDI 18/06/1998 574,890/=

18. WELLINGTONE CHAPIA OKUYUMBA 18/06/1998 494,950/= 72,388/= 50,000/=

19. HANNAH WAITHIRA WANJIRU 15/05/1998 414,429/= 48,107/= 50,000/=

20. JAMES MUSUNZA  MUTHUI 18/02/1998 198,656/= 36,083/= 50,000/=

21. DAVID NDEGWA WANJOHI 18/06/1998 60,343/= 5,888/= 50,000/=

22. JOSEPH MELAU TIOYANGA 18/02/1998

23 HENRY MBITI MULU 18/06/1998

24. SAMMY MADESHE SIMILA 31/10/1999 451,385 59,261

25. JULIUS THEURI WARIGU 21/06/2000 218,507/= 49,352/= 148/=

26. MARY NINGA KAMAU 15/05/1998 515,026/= 65,469/= 50,000/=

27. BENEDICT MUTIE KATUKU 15/09/2001 1,038,820/= 290/=

7,796,501/= 1,270,520/= 765,148/=

28. HEZRON KABURU BORO 12/07/2000

29. JOAN WAIRIMU KIGO JUNE 1998 640,445/= 80,306/= 100,000/=

30. DISHON MAINA NJOROGE 01/07/2000 94,999/= 36,125/= 100,000/=

31. STEPHEN GITAU KIMEMIA 18/02/1998 771,694/= 178,456/= 50,000/=

32. GAKWIL ERANA

33. CHARLES MBUTIA GITAGIA 18/06/1998 195,966/= 26,660/= 25,000/=

34. MICAH HOSEA AYIECHA 22/04/1998 1,050,221/= 300,333/= 54,909/=

35. PAUL KARIUKI WAHINGA 26/03/1998 130,625/= 22,507/= 72,000/=

36. ROSINA TALASI MUINGA 15/05/1998 188,078/= 19,626/= 50,000/=

37. JOHN MACHARIA MWARARI 31/03/1998

38. JOEL MUTISYA MUINDE 28/06/1995 654,369/=

39. JOHN MUNGAI NG’ETHE 31/05/1998 271,837/= 38,787/= 50,000/=

40. ESHMAEL NG’ETHE MUNGAI 31/07/1996 1,178,854/= 551,782/=

41. BENSON BENARD MULAMA MUSONGA 10/07/1998 255,002/= 26,210/= 100,000/=

42. SIMON MUNYUA KAMANO 21/06/2000 426,148/= 80,151/= 50,000/=

43. BENARD ANJIRI MAKANGA 17/08/1999 101,918/= 24,135/= 100,000/=

44. JOSEPH WAMBUGU WAHOME 26/10/2000

45. RICHARD NGAO 18/06/1998 1,165,897/= 141,715/= 100,000/=

46. JAMES MUKUNDI GATHARA 20/08/2002 3,759,951/= 964,401/= 50,000/=

47. HARUN ISMAIL SEBIT 30/04/1998

48. ABDUL ABDALLA MOHAMMED 22/04/1998 354,837/= 66,752/= 21,000/=

49. DAVID MUTHAMA NDUNDA 31/03/1998 268,381/= 34,740/=

50. SEPHEN MWANGI KIAMA 17/08/1999 317,666/= 66,919/= 100,000/=

51. PAUL JACKTON MALOBA 01/07/1998 215,798/=

52. MOHAMMED ABDULLAH KASIGARA 31/12/1995

53. EZEKIEL TOCHI MBINDI 10/12/1999 1,131,651/= 154,354/=

54. PETER MULI NYALA 30/06/1998 716,106/= 148,273/= 50,000/=

55. JAMES WACHIRA NJAU 18/02/1998 1,117,400/= 190,250/= 50,000/=

56. DANIEL KIHIKO KIMANI 19/05/1998 623,148/=

50,000/=

57. ALEX CHEGE MWANGI 27/07/1998

15,630,991/= 3,152,482/= 1,172,909/=

58. CHARLES KIVATI NGAU 18/02/1998 838,597/= 125,227/= 50,000/=

59. PETER OTHIAMBO OCHIENG 17/08/1999 295,235/= 61,896/= 100,000/=

60. NAPOLEON NATHAN KAMAU 12/05/1995

61. JAMES WAIGWE MUTURA 10/05/1995 371,865/=

62. ABUDU JUMA WAZIRI 31/12/1997 455,454/= 65,133/= 100,000/=

63. PETER MUNENE NDEGWA 31/03/1998 211,540/= 61,416/=

64. CLEMENT NJUNGE NDUNGU 31/10/1994 492,282/=

65. JOSHUA NGAHU GILBERT 11/03/1998 458,798/= 69,072/= 50,000/=

66. SALIM ISMAIL IBRAHIM 30/04/1998 1,083,948/= 227,679/= 50,000/=

67. MARK MUKOYA ABUOGA 01/05/1998 1,488,533/= 228,034/= 50,000/=

68. LAIRD MUSHIMBA SAMUEL 15/09/2001 231,077/= 76,377/= 50,000/=

69. ANN WANJIRU MWANGI 15/05/1998 625,783/= 83,821/= 50,000/=

70. GODFREY GITHUI WANGIGE 18/06/1998 1,252,685/= 295,941/= 10,000/=

71. GEORGE GWONDA NYAMARURU 06/09/1999 588,429/= 112,173/= 100,000/=

72. FRED KIARIE MAINA 18/02/1998 762,170/= 107,624/= 50,000/=

73. LEWIS WAMBUGU MUGO 31/08/1999 846,797/= 147,013/=

74. FRANCIS NGUGI NYARARA 31/03/1998 430,867/= 85,286/= 50,000/=

75. FRED OSOKO NYASAE 19/01/1998

76. JACKSON NULI NZAU 30/06/1996 1,202,654/=

77. GEORGE KANTI MITHEKO 15/03/1998 1,372,500/= 625,008/= 50,000/=

78. JOSEPH ONDURU ODUOR 18/06/1999

79. EDWARD MWAURA GACHIE 18/06/1998 50,000/= 34,788/=

80. JOEL MURIU KAMAU 31/10/2003 3,177,519/= 1,023,555/= 100,000/=

81. JEREMIAH RAMBIKI MACHINI 30/06/1998 984,531/= 245,252/= 50,000/=

82. ERASTUS KARAGO 29/04/1998 457,989/=

83. JOHN WABUGA KANGETHE 30/04/1998 561,161/= 79,759/= 50,000/=

84. WYCLIFF WELINGA KHAYO 06/09/1999

85. STEPHEN NJENGA KAHUKU 31/03/1998 113,104/= 29,275/=

86. PETER KIRUKU 30/11/2003 809,602/= 429,699/= 50,000/=

87. JAIRO OKUMU ONYANGOP 12/10/2001

88. JOHN KAMAU 18/06/1998 885,154/= 175,358/= 50,000/=

89. GEOFFREY NJOROGE 03/12/1997

90. GEORGE MUNYUA 13/04/1998 181,380/= 250,000/= 50,000/=

20,229,654/= 4,653,386/= 1,110,000/=

91. RAYMOND GACHOMBA 21/06/2000 304,632/= 95,262/=

92. CHARLES WAMBUGU MANGI 25/04/1996

93. JOSEPH OLOO 26/03/1998

94. JOSEPH KABOGO KARANJA 31/10/2003 567,224/= 305,700/=

95. FRANCIS OMONDI OBURE 24/05/1999 196,633/= 28,537/= 50,000/=

96. REGINALD NGANGA JAMES 18/06/1998 588,141/= 146,701/= 50,000/=

97. STEPHEN WAMBURA NJAU 31/03/1998 691,634/= 110,611/= 50,000/=

98. MATHEW GICHUHI KIRAGO 26/06/1996

99. TONKEI OLE MAPI 31/03/1998 516,620/= 81,230/= 10,000/=

100 JOSEPH MUTINDA 22/04/1998 186,800/= 33,147/= 50,000/=

101 BENARD MWILU MWOLOLO 27/06/1995 1,104,412

50,000/=

102 JOYCE NYAWIRA 28/08/1998 570,619/= 94,995/= 50,000/=

103 LYDIA MWANGI 15/05/1998 63,590/= 11,652/=

104 BONIFACE NGUI KIOKO 15/09/2001 1,287,489/= 197,264/= 50,000/=

105 BENJAMIN MUTISYA 22/04/1998 637,099/= 140,315/= 50,000/=

106 GRACE LILIAN ATHIANY 02/12/1997

107 PETER KIRUMA 19/05/2000

108 GEORGE CHARLES KIMOLO 17/08/1999 589,372/= 98,570/= 100,000/=

109 JOHN MATHINI MWAURA 25/06/1998

110 DAVID WACHIRA NDUNGU 31/03/1998 73,512/= 13,478/= 50,000/=

111 JAMES BEDAN KIGO 31/12/1998

112 ANTONY KIOKO 31/01/1998 1,067,107/= 179,425/= 50,000/=

113 MOSES NJERU MURIUKI 21/06/2000

114 MOHAMOOD HAMZA GITAU 30/11/1995

115 MAINGI MUNGAI KAGIRI 17/07/2000 661,101/= 182,026/= 75/=

116 DAVID MWANGANG MASYA 31/12/1997 270,613/= 17,668/= 50,000/=

117 JOSEPH MBOGO MURAGURI 06/09/1999 758,881/= 136,438/= 50,000/=

118 MBUGUA KIMATU MBUGUA 26/04/1995 458,645/=

119 MOSES KURIA MWANGI 18/02/198 1,037,906/= 235,641/= 50,000/=

120 JOHN RASAKI OYENG 06/09/1999 644,195/= 79,901/= 50,000/=

121 JOSEPH KIMANI 19/10/1998

122 JOSEPH MWANIKI 27/06/1995 481,897/= 130,371/= 100,000/=

123 HERMAN NJOROGE 22/04/1998 567,788/= 123,624/= 50,000/=

124 DAVID KIMWELE 15/09/2001 450,239/= 116,799/=

13,776,059/= 2,559,355/= 960,075/=

125 PETER MYSYOKA MUSESI 30/06/1996

126 MICHAEL NJOROGE KAMAU 05/07/2000 892,377/= 161,452/= 100,000/=

127 EDWIN RAGAK AWILI 31/10/1998 758,694/=

128 CALEB OPUKA 25/07/2000 503,328/= 118,886/= 22,198/=

129 JANUARY KAKUI 02/12/1997 245,971/= 27,072/=

130 ONESMUS KIRAGU 22/04/1998 720,254/=

131 CHRISTOPHER MWANGI NGOBU

132 GABRIEL NDUNGU 18/02/1998 197,048/= 34,867/= 50,000/=

133 JAMES NGANDU

134 JULIUS NDUNI 22/04/1998 322,902/= 35,425/= 50,000/=

135 SAMUEL MBUGUA MWANJI 03/10/2003 1,529,969/= 702,256/=

136 ZACHARIA KABIRU 22/04/1998 619,285/= 93,476/= 50,000/=

137 EDWARD NDEGWA 31/08/1998 2,220,330/= 537,356/=

138 J. T. NANDIE 31/12/1997 820,518/=

139 MWANIKI MUTUNGA NGULA 31/12/1997

140 MICHAEL NDUTA 19/01/1998 917,485/= 116,351/= 50,000/=

141 JONATHAN NDOLO 31/05/1998 1,230,181/= 314,455/= 50,000/-

142 HARRISON S. MWIKYA 15/05/1998 119,846/= 18,427/= 50,000/=

143 STANLEY M. MWAURA 24/05/199 1,255,215/= 317,343/= 8,330/=

144 JOHN M. NJOROGE 31/10/1994 367,974/=

145 JOHN NJOROGE GAKURU 03/04/1998 1,236,633/= 245,968/=

146 CATHERINE WANJIKU KIMANI 24/06/1998 235,569/= 48,654/= 50,000/=

147 PHYLIS WAMBUI 26/04/1995

148 RICHARD MURIITHI KARIUKI 30/06/1996 844,895/=

149 DONALD OWINO OKELLO 18/02/1998

150 ELIEZER ONCHIEKU 22/05/1998 1,257,726/= 153,399/= 50,000/=

151 STEPHEN N. KALII 10/03/1996 985,911/=

152 DAVID WAWERU KARIUKI 31/07/1999 699,789/=

153 NANCY E. NYAGA 22/04/1998 11,812/= 16,702/=

154 ROSEMARY WANJIKU NJOROGE 14/03/1998 153,596/=

155 JAMES KANGETHE NDAI 31/10/1994

18,147,008/= 2,942,125/= 530,528/=

156 JAMES KIHIKI KARIUKI 24/06/1998 154,789/= 20,103/= 50,000/=

157 GEORGE MBUGUA NJINO 31/03/1987 346,136/= 75,080/=

158 ZACKAYO NGIMEI NDUATI 31/03/1998

159 ERNEST GAKERO NDIRANGU

160 GEOFFREY MBURU MUNGAI

357,115/= 63,139/=

161 FELIX KIARIE MWANGI 18/02/1998 1,357,657/= 311,749/= 100,000/=

162 JOHN NJOGU GITONGA

163 DAVID KIGURU MWANGI 18/02/1998 443,089/= 73,917/= 50,000/=

164 BERNARD MBETU 30/04/1998 1,050,188/=

165 JOSEPH KEYA 18/06/1998 37,877/= 10,507/=

166 PETER MAINA KAMAU 31/01/1998 558,630/= 81,876/= 50,000/=

167 FRANCIS K. NUGUNA 15/05/1998 927,936/= 134,036/=

168 JULIUS NGUNJIRI WANYIRI 18/02/1998

100,000/=

169 EDWARD KARIUKI KAMWANA 31/03/1998 1,271,784/=

170 JOHN NJOROGE MBAGO 18/06/1998 341,882/= 80,784/= 17,700/=

171 SIMON RUTTOH 31/07/1998 387,796/= 27,763/= 50,000/=

172 ROBERT M. MUTUNGA 17/02/2006 1,096,973/=

173 ELIUD GITAU CHOMBA 30/06/1998 190,154/= 18,783/= 50,000/=

174 KITHUKA KIOKO 25/04/1995 391,779/=

175 SOLOMON MUTISYA 15/09/2001 473,790/= 127,587/= 100,000/=

176 WILSON MUTUA MUTUNE 30/06/1998

177 CHARLES WATHIGA 31/10/1998 1,002,489/= 144,056/= 50,000/=

178 MARCUS MURUBE 31/03/1998

179 JAMES GITAU 18/06/1998 1,237,574/=

180 JAMES MWANGI THUO 18/02/1998 2,553,840/= 82,277/= 50,000/=

181 LAWRENCE M. KUBURENDI 31/10/1998 751,217/=

182 JOSEPH MWANGI KIMANI

183 GEOFFREY K. MUCHEKE 18/06/1998 669,173/= 77,672/= 50,000/=

184 KEFFARS KARIUKI KAGUANYU 30/09/1998 372,756/=

185 SAMMY MWANGI 18/02/1998

186 NANCY MWANGI 15/05/1998 294,725/= 26,912/=

187 DANIEL MAINA RUTUNU 31/07/1999 154,181/= 41,182/=

188 ANN KAMBA 30/06/199

16,423,530/= 1,397,423/= 717,700/=

189 SAMUEL MUCHIRI MUIRURI 31/12/1997 264,144/= 26,093/= 100,000/=

190 BENSON IRUNGU MWANGI

1,947,067/= 285,158/= 100,000/=

191 JULIUS KARIUKI 02/12/1997 204,648/= 27,072/=

192 JAMES N. KIRANGI 30/10/1998

193 EDWIN KABUI KAHARA 31/10/1998 587,770/= 86,776/= 50,000/=

194 EUNICE WANJUGU KAHUIRIA FEB. 1998 778,885/= 166,348/= 50,000/=

195 EDWARD N, KAIRU 25/04/1998 420,518/=

196 JOSEPH M. NTHENGE 21/06/2000 406,638/= 80,638/= 50,000/=

197 MUEMA DANIEL 22/01/1998 206,000/= 33,147/= 50,000/=

198 NZIOKA WAMBUA 18/02/1998 1,119,592/= 213,583/= 50,000/=

199 PATRICK N. NDUNDA 22/04/1998 1,182,483/= 251,122/= 50,000/=

200 JONES KISANI NGULI 15/06/1999 269,603/= 51,845/=

201 FRANCIS MATHEKA MULWA 11/05/1995 604,884/=

202 DOMINIC NDERO 29/13/1996

203 GEORGE NUANDIKO KATHISYA 26/03/1998

204 TOM  KABITI VENGE 30/03/1998 1,319,207/=

205 ROBINSON NDUNGU NGUGI 30/06/1998 1,134,231/= 170,182/= 50,000/=

206 AUGUSTINE MUTEMI 30/06/1998 179,072/= 19,489/=

207 GEORGE MUIA MUISYA 27/09/1999 169,374/= 25,823/= 100,000/=

208 EVAN NJURI NGANGIRA 09/07/1998 709,130/= 122,624/=

209 JOHN NGUGI WANJAU 31/03/1998 434,689/=

10,400/=

210 MUSA MBONGO 31/03/1996 890,489/= 229,035/= 10,000/=

211 DUNCAN MWANZIA

80,733/=

212 DAVID NGUGI

213 PETRONILLA WANJIRU 25/04/1996 662,952/= 171,872/=

214 JOSEPH MATATA MUTUA 10/03/1996 595,706/=

215 KADOGO PASCAL 04/06/1998 871,781/= 117,730/= 100,000/=

216 PATRICK KIBUNJA NDUNGU 18/06/1998 134,334/= 17,738/=

217 MOSES MWIKYA LELU 18/02/1998 1,778,535/=

218 EVANS MUROKO MITHAMO 03/12/1997 500,519/=

219 FRANCIS K. MACHARIA 31/10/1994 629,413/=

220 STEPHEN GITAU KIMANI 09/09/1998 148,083/= 46,029/= 50,000/=

221 JOSEPH KINYANJUI 22/04/1998 858,603/= 125,280/= 50,000/=

19,089,083/= 2,267,839/= 920,400/=

222 LABAN GICHARA NJOROGE 28/06/1995 920,177/=

223 JOHN KARANI JURIUKI 01/03/1998 840,040/= 111,611/= 50,000/=

224 JAMES MURIU GICHARU 30/06/1996 932,000/=

225 STEPHEN WANGOMBE THEURI 15/12/2003

226 NGUGI KIRAGU 18/06/1998 202,832/= 50,317/= 50,000/=

227 JULIUS N. MULI 31/10/1998 669,330/= 109,278/= 50,000/=

228 STEPHEN MUGO 31/12/1997 741,028/= 138,103/= 50,000/=

229 JAMES MUTHIMA MATHENTE 30/06/1998

230 ABDALLA A. KIBARABARA 02/12/1997 154,220/= 27,072/=

231 JOHN MUSERU WATAKO 18/02/1998 1,065,643/= 148,010/=

232 BENJAMIN KAVOI MWIKYA

1,284,767/= 368,749/=

233 SAMUEL MUNENE KAGUGANI 31/03/1998 424,524/= 101,888/= 100,000/=

234 BONIFACE WANJEMA NJENGA 30/06/1998 101,026/= 17,201/= 50,000/=

235 ISAAC MAINA 31/07/1998 366,058/= 40,508/= 50,000/=

236 TABITH NYOKABI NJUGUNA 15/05/1998 506,497/= 63,806/= 50,000/=

237 ROSE WANGARI 15/05/1998 535,814/= 67,046/= 50,000/=

238 RITALIND NJERI NJOROGE 18/02/1998 497,332/= 83,712/= 50,000/=

239 JOSEPH MUCHEMI MAINGI 18/02/1998 417,181/= 72,674/= 50,000/=

240 REUBEN MURIITHI MUNYIRI 28/02/1995 531,429/=

241 DICKSON KINULA KITOO 22/04/1998 1,164,785/= 185,710/= 50,000/=

242 MOSES N. NJAGI 22/04/1998 279,985/= 48,995/= 50,000/=

243 TIMOTHY GATHUA

244 G. M. NGARUIYA 18/06/1998 664,097/= 132,055/= 50,000/=

245 PAUL RIMUI MUHIA 30/04/2003

246 JOHN KABAA 13/07/1998 705,118/= 14,378/=

247 HASSAN SORA 18/02/1998 1,450,847/= 17,252/= 50,000/=

248 S. M. MUHIA 18/06/1998 1,596,866/= 59,948/= 50,000/=

249 DAVID MUTIND MWANGAGI 18/06/1996 894,915/=

250 WILSON MABOI 31/12/1998 547,147/=

251 JOEL MARIM TOO 31/10/1994

252 JOHN MWANIKI 23/04/1998 1,040,562/= 190,969/= 50,000/=

253 JACKSON MULONZI 21/06/2000 22,940/= 38,371/= 50,000/=

17,641,660/= 1,718,904/= 1,000,000/=

254 JOHN GITORO

97,568/= 14,777/= 50,000/=

255 JAMES AMOLO 17/06/1996

256 SIMON MUTISYA 30/06/1998 193,392/= 36,107/=

257 NELSON KINGA 28/06/1995

258 KENNETH KAGETO

259 KARIM H. KARIM 31/12/1997 460,155/= 62,059/= 100,000/=

260 SYMON WAIROBI GATUMA 23/04/2003 1,109,363/= 624,183/=

261 PETERSON AIGURU 22/04/1998 668,587/=

262 BENJAMIN WAMAI 31/05/1995 607,496/=

263 JOSEPH MUTHAMA 31/03/1998

264 WALTER ONG’ANG’O 31/12/1997 301,396/= 44,992/= 100,000/=

265 DANIEL MWAURA 31/03/1998 1,522,797/= 274,111/= 60,000/=

266 DOMINIC MURIU KUNGU 30/06/1998 160,792/= 19,506/=

267 JOSEPH K. KUNGU 31/10/1998 246,644/= 27,363/= 10,000/=

268 PETER KIGUTA NDIRANGU

1,722,592/=

269 CLEMENCE WAKESHO MWADIME 21/09/1995 373,448/=

270 ALBANUS K. NZAU 21/06/2000 307,383/= 62,956/= 259/=

271 BENARD K. SILA 27/03/1995

272 RAMADHAN NUGHASHE 27/07/1998 296,500/= 25,592/=

273 YAHYA HUSSEIN GICHURU 11/02/1998

274 MESHACK MOMANYI 17/08/1999 162,887/= 67,398/= 100,000/=

275 FRANCIS DAVID KIOKO 31/05/1998 1,448,399/= 216,625/= 50,000/=

276 STEPHEN NDERITU 25/04/2003 551,124/= 135,330/= 50,000/=

277 FRANCIS MURI MWANGI 23/04/2003 667,749/= 536,097/=

278 HENRY SOMBA MAILU 25/04/2003

80/=

279 HUMPHREY REREI MBUGUA 09/03/1998 844,375/= 184,860/=

280 MICHAEL N. MWANIKI 18/11/1998 678,681/= 109,486/= 50,000/=

281 IRENE NGURE NYAWIRA 31/05/1998 1,876,432/= 544,705/=

282 BENARD NZIMBA 31/12/1997 647,696/= 88,120/= 100,000/=

283 CHARLES ODINGA 03/12/1997 918,899/= 209,842/=

284 SILA MUYA 18/06/1998 468,366. 86 107,451. 50 50,000/=

285 FRED NGENO SOI 15/10/2001 551,503. 66

286 HADIJA NJERI ABDALLAH

287

16,884,225. 2 3,391,560. 50 720,339/=

288 MARTIN NJIRAINI MURAGE

289 FRANCIS KIMOTHO 19/10/1998 947,942. 86 46,573. 00 50,000/=

290 WILSON MURIITHI 18/09/1998 828,620. 98 101,742. 92

291 DANIEL MAGOTHI MUHUYU 18/02/1998 672,349. 50 137,712/= 50,000/=

292 GABRIEL M. METHO 21/06/2000 128,304. 15 58,326. 30 50,000/=

293 SOLOMON K. KARIO 18/06/1998

294 AUGUSTINE NYAKONDO 23/04/2003 1,688,488. 67 500,466. 80

295 CHRISPINE NYAGA 31/03/1998 526,674. 90 110,323/=

296 NICHOLAS MUTEI KIRIMI 25/04/1996

297 ROBERT MURIUKI 31/10/2003 2,934,237/= 1,334,172/=

298 PETER M. MBUI 18/02/1998 1,450,227/= 429,828/=

299 MOHAMMED JOHN SHIKUKU 31/03/1998 995,586/= 169,451/=

300 JUSTUUS MWANZIA MAITHYA 26/03/1996 715,413/=

301 MESHACK DERO 4/16/1998 248,171/= 179,209/=

302 ABDURAHAMAN RAMADHANI 24/10/2001

303 LAMECH MOGAKA 18/02/1998 190,257/= 32,273/=

304 RICHARD AGUNDA MASINDA 15/06/1999

305 PETER MURIU MUIGA 8/02/1998 575,823/= 99,927/= 50,000/=

306 PETER MUTURI NJOGO 25/04/2003 3,407,700/= 607,023/= 100,000/=

307 JAMES KIMANI WAINAINA 31/03/1998 127,142/= 27,964/=

308 JOSEPH A. BWANA 27/03/1998 1,543,649/=

14,495/=

309 EDWIN NGANGIRA GATEI 18/2/1998

310 NAHASHON M. KINGI 30/6/1995 452,217/=

311 DAVID JOE MWANGI KARIU FEB 1998

312 SAMUEL NYANGIRA MUTEI 18/2/1998 937,490/= 244,129/= 50,000/=

313 ONESMUS N. NGOILOVOI 18/06/1998 673,236/= 76,995/=

314 DAVID OLOO OUKO 30/4/2003 3,115,096/=

315 GABRIEL NJUGUNA KARIUKI 13/3/1998 779,586/= 161,810/=

316 JOHANA MUCHIMI WACHIRA 26/03/1998

317 ELIUD OUMA GOME 15/06/1999 1,089,927/= 164,871/=

318 JOHN BUNYI GICHARU 18/06/1998 882,407/= 126,363/= 50,000/=

319 FRANCIS NJAAGA TIFUS 31/12/1997 151,176/= 22,556/=

320 STEPHEN K. MUNGAI

321 MARGARET O. ODHIAMBO 15/05/1998 263,612/= 46,861/= 50,000/=

25,325,333. 06 4,678,572. 02 464,495/=

322 GEORGE K. GICHOHI 26/03/1998 1,392,144/= 244,694/= 50,000/=

323 MARGARET W. KINYUA 26/03/1998 542,233/= 79,579/= 50,000/=

324 ROBINSON M. GAKUNJI 19/07/2000 598,906/= 141,114/= 50,000/=

325 JOSEPH MAINA MACHARIA 30/06/1998 641,440/= 61384/= 50,000/=

326 SAMSON ONYANGONGAO 3/10/2000 887,867/=

327 CHRISTOPHER NDICHU MBOCHE 31/03/1998 478,121/= 87,494/= 50,000/=

328 DANIEL NJOROGE KAMAU 15/06/1999

329 JAMES ABUKUSE OCHAMI 31/10/1994 400,137/= 61,690/= 60,000/=

330 KANYA KAMAU 31/10/1994 877,897/=

331 SAMUEL GACHURI 15/09/2001 1,169,830/= 216,397/=

332 ROBERT MUCHUNO NJUGUNA 19/05/1999 1,331,781/= 302,665/= 100,000/=

333 PEETR L. OPILI 21/10/1994

334 EPHRAIM M. NJOROGE

1,436,118/= 584,266/= 10,000/=

335 PETER MBURU KIBUGI 1995

336 ROBERT MBUTHIA MUNGAI 18/06/1996 1,833,305/= 153,532/=

337 MACHARIA MUTURI 30/04/1998 728,690/= 80,619/=

338 ISAAC NJINE KARIUKI 30/09/1995 928,103/=

339 FRANCIS M. KANGANGI 18/06/1998

340 JECONIA O. ANINDO 24/05/1999 436,711/= 55,688/= 50,000/=

341 SOLOMON OTIENO ANINDO 12/06/1998 1,204,466/= 193,295/= 50,000/=

342 JOSPHAT MUKUNDI KINUTHIA 25/04/1996

343 FREDRICK KIBOI KIHORO 27/09/1999 962,401/= 142,766/=

344 GEOFFREY WAIYEGO 18/12/1998 432,270/= 43,432/= 50,000/=

345 GORDON MISANGO 31/10/2003 1,429,927/= 579,210/=

346 JOSEPH K.MAINA 17/07/2000 525,730/= 107,825/= 50,000/=

347 SIMON NJATHI MUTORA 28/02/1998

348 SAMUEL M. THAIRU 31/07/1998 970,222/= 138,089/= 50,000/=

349 ALLAN KABUGI 31/07/1998 1,149,448/= 238,403/=

350 JOHN MUTHORERI 22/04/1998 228,199/= 100,235/=

351 IBRAHIM MURATHA 31/12/1997 874,041/= 201,248/=

352 JUSTUS MUTEMI WAMBUA 31/05/1998 1,280,834/= 232,986/= 50,000/=

22,740,911/= 4,04,611/= 720,000/=

353 ALRED KIBE 3/12/1997 1,670,343/= 106,013/=

354 PETER GICHOBI 15/05/1998 761,043/= 136,728/= 50,000/=

355 ROBERT W. NDIANGUI

558,786/= 73,466/= 50,000/=

356 PHILIP KILONZO NWANZIA 30/06/1998 693,287/= 117,036/=

357 EDWARD K. THAIRU 31/07/1998 244,578/=

358 JAMIA A. BABALA 18/16/1998 1,309,650/= 174,727/= 100,000/=

359 JOSEPH WAITHAKA MBUGUA 5/05/1998 933,850/= 199,534/= 60,000/=

360 GEORGE M. THUO 31/10/1998

361 JULIUS MWANGONDI 31/10/2003 1,531,701/= 566,738/= 50,000/=

362 GEOFFREY K. WAKABA 18/02/1998 768,062/= 153,429/= 50,000/=

363 BONIFACE K. MASAI 31/05/1998 1,223,068/= 213,403/= 50,000/=

364 NICHOLAS MACKENZIE 18/9/1998 1,219,092/= 195,994/= 50,000/=

365 DANIEL NGEWA KIOLI 20/09/1995

366 BENJAMIN W. MATUVA 31/10/2003 1,161,562/= 564,155/= 50,000/=

367 ALEX WAMBANDI 15/05/1998 201,696/= 18,960/= 50,000/=

368 HARRISON AMULI 17/08/1999 284,301/= 50,729/= 100,000/=

369 PETER K. KIMANI 18/02/1998 150,877/= 23,682/= 50,000/=

370 HENRY K. KARANJA 22/04/1998 59,513/= 81,176/=

371 FRANCIS BWIRE 31/12/1997 1,426,099/=

372 MARTIN S. MUTUNGI 30/06/1998 195,293/= 18,584/= 50,000/=

373 WANJOHI WACHIRA 28/06/1995

374 JAMES N, GICHEHA 31/12/1997 524,132/= 79,689/= 100,000/=

375 MICHAEL W. KARIUKI 31/12/1997 300,244/=

376 HANNINGTON KAVU 18/01/1999

377 CHARLOTTE MDOE 31/12/1977 26,514/=

378 RACHAEL KAVU 31/12/1977 35,951/= 8,760/=

379 LYDIA MBITHI 31/12/1997 549,254/= 86,068/= 100,000/=

380 MR. IRUNGU KAMAU 31/12/1997 286,278/= 42,930/= 100,000/=

381 BARRACK HABWE 28/06/1995 2,227,153/= 21,364/=

382 JONATHAN M. SUMUNU 31/03/1998 213,719/= 61,700/= 50,000/=

383 ROBERT G. MBOA 31/03/1998 415,927/= 76,355/= 50,000/=

384 LEONARD K. IRUNGU

385 ANDREW N. KARIUKI 1998

386 HERMAN G. MBUGUA

18,971,973/= 3,071,220/= 1,160,000/=

387 THOMAS M. MUTUKU 31/12/1995 480,966/=

388 JULIUS G. MACHARIA 31/12/1997

389 JOSEPH KOROSSI 31/12/1997 150,582/= 11,768/= 50,000/=

390 ERNEST KOSKEY 30/06/1998

391 FREDRICK KIRUGA 31/05/1998 708,553/=

392 DANIEL MACHARIA 16/11/1994 506,099/=

393 JIM KABUE 31/03/1998

394 JOB MWANZIA 30/06/1998 50,7296/= 54,935/=

395 JOHN M. KIILU 28/02/1998 469,032/= 91,056/= 50,000/=

396 CHARLES OUMA 26/03/1998 128,847/= 30,984/= 100,000/=

397 TERRY G. WALKER 28/03/1995

398 SIMON K. MWANGI 30/05/1998

399 JOHN C. NDUATI 24/06/1998 517,602/= 72,462/= 50,000/=

400 JONATHANN MUIGAI 6/03/1998 567,644/= 84,070/= 50,000/=

401 LAWRENCE NDUNGU NGUGI 31/05/1995 383,012/=

402 JOHN M. MALUKI 30/09/1995 367,044/=

403 DAVID MUNGAI 20/08/2002

404 WARIO J. BONAYA 24/05/1999 803,229/= 132,938/=

405 TIMOTHY S. KIILU 3/12/1997 1,758,824/= 381,813/=

406 ISAACK N. NGUGI 21/06/2000 95,868/= 32,226/=

407 JULIUS KM MBUTHIA 30/06/1998

408 RICHARD S. KILONZO 31/12/1997 786,632/=

409 MARTIN NJOROGE 18/06/1998

410 GEORGE N, KARIRU 30/04/1996 749,258/=

411 SIMON K. MBUGUA 31/03/1998 1,155,927/= 149,473/=

412 DICKSON NJOROGE 13/12/1997 999,241/=

413 CHRIANT KINYALE 9/06/1998 260,040/= 48,317/=

414 PATRICK N. KIMATA 18/06/1998 908,757/= 194,835/= 50,000/=

415 ALFRED B. OBUNGA 15/03/1996 1,249,200/=

416 JAMES ANGAWA ONYANGO MAY 2003 135,939/= 140,925/= 100,000/=

417 SAMUEL KAHUNYO 30/06/1995

418 DAVID KAMANGA 30/04/1998

419 JOSEPH K. MBUGUA 22/07/200 205,415/= 46,677/= 50,000/=

420 ROBERT M. KITHEKA 31/03/1998 1,211,260/= 280,707/= 60,000/=

421 STEPHEN W. KANYI

14,650,687/= 1,753,176/= 660,000/=

422 LOIS WAMBUI NDIRANGU 18/02/1998 786,645/= 180,858/=

423 PETER THEURI 1/07/1998 415,881/= 68,325/=

424 F. M. GATHIRU 3/12/1997

425 KITEMA KIMULI 31/10/1994

426 JOSEPH IRUNGU WAHAGI 26/03/1998 401,680/= 73,011/= 50,000/=

427 PETER KIHARO 18/02/1998 1,008,182/= 268,442/= 100,000/=

428 MAHARIA RERAI 18/02/1998 633,600/= 83,339/= 50,000/=

429 EDWARD BENSON THAIRU 25/04/2003 1,409,514/= 274,129/=

430 ELIUD MUCUNU KARIMI 26/07/1994

431 JOSEPH MUHUNI NJOROGE 22/10/1994 705,214/=

432 JOSEPH WANYAMA 18/06/1998 231,103/= 44,671/=

433 LEONARD NDAWA MBULU 1999

434 JOSEPH KIPNGETICH KIRUI 30/06/1998 361,866/=

435 CHRISTOPHER MARITIM 20/11/1998 443,257/= 61,094/=

436 JAMLECK WAMAI NDIRANGU 26/03/1998 177,687/= 35,460/=

437 MUNENI KIRUBU

438 PETER MAITHYA MWENGA 30/06/1996 819,236/=

439 PETER MUCHIRI MWANGI 18/06/1998 519,758/= 72,995/= 50,000/=

440 PETER HUMPHREY KARIUKI

441 FRANCIS KIMANI 30/06/1998 468,533/= 76,324/= 50,000/=

442 GEORGE KIMANI NUTHONI 12/07/1999 130,014/= 49,586/=

443 CHARLES MAINA GITHINJI 25/04/2003 1,208,923/= 283,851/= 100,000/=

444 SIMON M. GICHU 22/05/1998 576,526/=

445 NJAMBI NGAARA

446 LEONARD KITUMBA KAVULUNZE 21/06/2000 220,258/= 45,938/= 50,000/=

447 JOHN MWANGI MWANIKI 10/12/1999 179,939/= 23,066/= 100,000/=

448 SAMMY KINYUGO KIHUNGU 31/03/1998 390,310/= 63,367/=

449 PAULINE WAIRIMU 2/12/1997 923,188/= 70,315/= 50,000/=

450 DAVID M. KITAKA 18/06/1998 87,918/= 124,498/=

451 PETER MUTEI KILONZO 15/06/1999 266,429/= 57,706/= 50,000/=

452 EDWARD MUTHUSI MUSILI 19/10/1998 189,807/= 17,298/= 50,000/=

453 SAMSONM MUASYA MUTUNGU 31/12/1997 319,583/= 37,134/= 100,000/=

12,875,01/= 2,011,107/= 800,000/=

454 DENNIS KINYUA NYAMU 6/09/1999 329,647/= 81,645/= 100,000/=

455 MICHAEL OKUMU LAZARUS OPATA 23/03/1998 1,230,476/= 226,152/= 50,000/=

456 GERALD KIBUTHU 22/04/1998 304,975/= 51,936/= 50,000/=

457 DANIEL NYOIKE NGANGA

458 CHRISTOPHER KIBUTHU 22/04/1998 1,131,941/= 276,690/= 50,000/=

459 PATRICK MUNYIRI GICHUKI 20/03/1998 643,836/= 124,417/= 50,000/=

460 DAVID NGANGA WAMAI 30/06/1996 1,016,293/=

461 PETER KARIUKI NGIGI 26/03/1998 581,056/=

462 ONESPHOROUS K. KARIANJAHI 30/04/1998 1,087,307/= 199,727/= 50,000/=

463 JOHN KAMAU 17/01/2008 1,020,195/= 308,467/= 100,000/=

464 JACKSON KIVIUITU NGUNZE 22/04/1998 694,446/= 144,419/= 50,000/=

465 NELSON MAKUMI MANGI 3/07/2000 682,069/= 140,832/= 50,000/=

466 WILLIM K. MUNGUTI 9/05/1995 3,009,242/= 107,742/=

467 JOHN BWALA OBWOGO 28/02/1995 677,598/=

468 SAMMY WANJOOHI GITHINJI 31/03/1998

469 FREDRICK GICHUMA KAGWAINI 31/03/1998

470 ALBANOS KITAKA MULWA 21/06/2000 883,142/=

471 MWASYA MULIKO KATHUKU 30/06/1995 622,339/=

472 CHARLES NJOROGE MACHARIA 31/10/1994 672,069/=

473 JOHN GICHOMO NGIGI 30/03/1998

474 FESTUS OWINO ODANDO 6/09/1999 99,888/= 16,425/=

475 BENARD GITHAIGA GITHUI 30/06/1998 345,814/=

476 BENEDICT MBILO JOHN 31/12/1997 763,155/= 98,339/= 100,000/=

477 RAHAB MUKAMI WANJOHI 18/02/1998 173,056/= 33,728/= 50,000/=

478 GEORGE WAWERU KIMANI 18/06/1998 1,135,309/= 197,216/= 50,000/=

479 DANSON NYAGA NGARI 31/03/1998 265,254/= 29,431/=

480 CHARLES MBURU KINYANJUI 30/10/1994

481 DAVID KAHURA KIMOTHO 31/08/1998 352,806/= 183,518/=

482 ZACHARIA INJELULA 31/12/1997 485,408/= 170,907/=

483 DANIEL MULWA MUSAU 31/10/1998

18,207,321/= 2,601,713/= 750,000/=

484 JAMES MWANGI WAINAINA 31/05/1998 413,689/=

485 PAUL MUIYA MUIA 19/10/1998 684,013/= 113,732/= 50,000/=

486 BENARD KIMANZI MASILA 25/07/2000 530,482/=

487 FRANCIS KAIRU THAIRU 18/06/1998 170,220/= 55,511/=

488 ERNEST IRUNGU WACHIRA 31/03/1998

489 SAMUEL THUO KIMANI 11/05/1995

490 JEREMIAH MJLANDI 18/06/1998 724,328/= 131,803/=

491 MATTHEW KARIUKI MUCEMBI 25/02/1996

492 PETER THIRIKWA MWANGI

493 JOHN KINUTHIA MURIUKI 31/10/1994

494 WILLIAM MUSYOKA MUTUKU 31/12/1997 378,897/= 52,644/=

495 GEORGE MWATHI 24/05/1999 402/824/= 63,956/= 50,000/=

496 NDUNGU NJOROGE 31/10/1994

497 JAMES MUIGAI KIRAGURI 30/06/1998 262,446/= 5,034/= 50,000/=

498 STANELY MBURU NGIGI 26/10/2001 268,026/= 69,135/=

499 STEPHEN MURIUNGI NCEEENE 20/03/2006 1,196,298/= 573,932/= 50,000/=

500 TITO KAKULI 26/03/1998 433,704/= 74,205/=

501 KEFAH ANYANJE 18/02/1998 674,118/= 83,289/=

502 PETER MWANGI KAGWANJA 15/05/1998 123,382/= 7,686/=

503 STNALEY KIIMU RINGERA 12/02/1996

504 PETER ANTHONY MUREITHI 21/06/2000 143,809/= 306,442/= 100,000/=

505 MUTHUI MUSYOKA 31/10/1994

506 NASHON MUIGAI KAGO 20/07/2000 284,309/= 60,205/= 50,000/=

507 JUSTUS MBAYI ABALA 15/06/1999 302,962/= 69,044/=

508 TAABU ALI GUCHU 2/12/1997

509 MOHAMMED ALI GODORO 26/13/1998

510 JOSEPH WANDERE DOTO 15/05/1998 529,111/= 91,635/=

511 ESTHER KINGESI 30/08/1999 307,699/= 80,677/= 50,000/=

512 FRANCINAH NUGUNA ICHAGICHU 18/02/1998 261,719/= 40,677/= 30,000/=

513 JOSEPH KIIO MUTUNGI 25/04/2003 3,054,647/= 623,001/=

514 PATRICK MUTUA KIILU 30/08/1999 1,422,243/= 158,525/=

12,568,926/= 2,661,133/= 430,000/=

515 MWINZI MULI 26/03/1996 513,956/=

516 DANIEL MUTUA MWANZIA 18/09/1998 238,372/= 19,052/= 50,000/=

517 TITUS MWANGI KAMAU 18/02/1998 1,933,451/= 378,110/= 50,000/=

518 FRANCIS KAPALA 02/06/1995

519 JULIUS NDUNGU KINYUA 21/06/2000 283,861/= 66,051/= 100,000/=

520 JOSEPH NTHIWA NTHUKU 16/11/1998 285,623/=

50,000/=

521 ROBINSON ODHIAMBO 31/10/1998 590,294/= 83,577/= 50,000/=

522 SILAS OKEYO ASKO 09/11/1998 571,627/= 89,349/= 50,000/=

523 FRANCIS MBAI KITELA 31/03/1998

524 JONATHAN KAMANDE THIRU

525 PETER WACHRA NJUKI 22/05/1995

526 BERNADETTE NGUTA MWIKALI 15/05/1996 799,187/=

527 JOEL MUA ULANGA 30/04/1995 919,659/=

528 NZUKI MUTUA 30/04/1995 466,285/=

529 GEORGE MUINDE NYUMU 31/03/1998 442,537/= 80,090/= 50,000/=

530 SEPHEN MWANGI KANYI 15/06/1999 177,810/= 76,198/=

531 DAVIND KANYI MUNYUNGI 31/10/1994 1,508,162/=

532 SIMON WACHIRA NDUGIRE 19/10/1998

533 GODFREY MWANGI MUTHUMBI 08/06/1998 472,194/=

534 LAWRENCE KINYUA GEORGE 14/02/1995 733,752/=

535 JOHN GATEI NGANGIRA 31/05/1998 230,522/= 31,258/=

536 JULIUS MITHYA 18/06/1998 185,170/= 8,201/= 50,000/=

537 MWANZIA MALUTA

174,709/= 36,312/=

538 BEATRICE KIBE AIGUMO 31/07/2001

539 JOHNSON KARANJA KAMAU 01/05/1996 1,966,871/=

540 SWYNNERTON NAZOI ACHALA 5/02/2001 465,542/= 106,107/= 14,000/=

541 LAWRENCE NGUGI NGANGA 19/11/1996 183,284/=

542 BACHO KIHONO 10/03/1996 857,549/=

543 STEPHEN GITAKA MWAURA 30/06/1996 1,104,682/=

544 JOSEPH ABUOGA OKEDAH 13/05/1998 1,070,111/=

16,175,210/= 1,172,764/= 514,000/=

545 PETER GICHANGA MUTHUNGU

2,663,046/=

546 JOHN MWANGANGI MWABU 20/09/1995

547 SOLOMON SONYI MUTEMI 31/10/1998

548 SAMUEL NGANGA 28/06/1995

549 PETER NDETI KITUKU 18/02/1998 625,794/= 89,435/= 50,000/=

550 JOHN NDEGWA NGURIBU 10/03/2006

551 ANASTASIA NGINA MULWA 17/08/199 69,285/= 53,502/= 50,000/=

552 CHALES MURIUKI GATHURA 30/06/1996

553 ADRAIN KANGORO LAIKURU 24/05/1999

554 NICHOLAS IRUNGU GICHARU 18/02/1998 169,816/= 23,820/=

555 JOSEPH NYAKUNDI NYANGAU 3/06/1998

556 DAVID NJOROGE KAMAU 28/06/1995 462,024/=

557 OMAR ALI 2/12/1997 701,697/= 11,515/= 100,000/=

558 AHMED MOHAMMED KOMBO 31/12/1997 661,610/= 115,221/= 100,000/=

559 PETER NJUGUNA MARARO 31/07/1998 266,236/= 23,845/=

560 CHARLESTONE MBUVI 30/06/1999

561 GEORGE KARIUKI KIBE 31/12/1997 1,746,723/= 1,746,723/= 536,808/=

562 JEREMIAH BAIBAYA 28/02/1999 893,822/=

563 JOHN AUPDO 22/04/1998

564 CHARLES GATHUTHI 28/02/1998 537,122/= 114,649/= 50,000/=

565 JAMES MWANGI HOROHO 21/10/1994

566 WYCLIFE GESICHO MOEMI 21/06/2000 31,590/= 78,729/=

567 ETHAN MURAGE NGECHO 2/16/1995 827,792/=

568 AHMED KIARIE NJONGE 2/12/1997

569 MWINYUI JUMA WAZIRI

570 FRANCIS KASING MASILA 15/07/1999 2,425,111/= 996,778/= 200,000

571 PETER MWALUGA MUYUSA 21/02/2006 2,080,846/= 965,888/= 100,000/=

572 NICHOLAS MGWILI KAVOI 18/06/1998 344,573/=

573 FLORENCEMUSAU 18/06/1998 150,764/= 160,030/= 200,000/=

574 BENSON WAWERU KIRAGU

582,321/= 145,940/= 7,000/=

575 SAMUEL NJENGA GACHEMI

212,931/= 64,703/=

15,453,103/= 4,590,778/= 1,393,808/=

576 LYDIA MENE MUSYOKI 13/05/1998 180,340/= 19,713/=

577 JAMES MICHINO 09/04/1998

578 IBRAHIM WACHIRA BILALI 31/07/2000 1,556,354/=

579 JOHN KINGI 15/05/1998 376,683/= 64,213/= 50,000/=

580 KIMWELE KIMANZI 31/04/1994

581 PETER KIMANI GICHINGA 18/02/1998 833,390/= 116,680/= 50,000/=

582 JULIUS NDERITY KABUBI 03/07/2000 743,048/= 163,155/= 1,000/=

583 KENNETH GICHINA THUO 31/12/1997 231,695/= 13,805/= 100,000/=

584 NAPHTALY KUNYIHA 3/12/1997 1,569,757/= 493,759/=

585 FELICITAS NDUNGE SILA 31/12/1997 1,353,878/= 227,757/= 150,000/=

586 PETER KIMATA 30/11/2003

587 MIRRIAM SIMILA MAYANGA 30/09/1998 297,595/=

588 RAPHAEL WAINAINA MBOGO 18/06/1998 2,491,197/= 953,287/= 100,000/=

589 FRANCIS MAINA KIEME 30/05/1998

590 MUTETI NDAVI

591 PERIS OGANDA 20/06/1998 59,563/= 11,833/= 30,000/=

592 NICHOLAS KARANJA 18/02/1998

593 MARY KABIRU 31/05/1998 192,730/=

594 JOHN NGONDU NJERU 18/06/1998 36,856/= 12,340/= 25,000/=

595 MWANDIKWA MUNYASIA 06/03/1996

596 FRANCIS MUINDI KIOKO 31/10/2003 1,580,949/= 689,054/=

597 BENSON KABUGI 18/06/1998 738,188/= 196,632/= 50,000/=

598 JOHN KIBE WANJA 28/02/1995

599 GEORGE MBITHI MUSAU 31/05/1998

600 HUMPHREY N. KINYUA 15/02/1999 1,037,222/= 290,511/= 50,000/=

601 ALBERT N. KIHARA 31/07/1998 482,686/= 76,034/= 50,000/=

602 DAVID THAIRU GATHECA 18/09/1998

603 DANIEL NJUGUNA NGANGA

604 TUGAA IDI 15/05/1998 596,462/= 78,885/= 50,000/=

605 JAMES MURAI KINYANJUI 18/06/1998 390,474/= 83,462/= 50,000/=

606 JOHN MAINA 31/10/1994

607 COSMAS KIOKO MASEE 30/06/1998 718,047/=

608 MUTHUI MULYONGOI 30/04/1996 982,019/=

609 ELIJAH NJUGUNA 21/06/2000 49,149/= 159,287/=

16,498,282/= 3,700,407/= 756,000/=

610 PETER NDUNGU 31/10/1994 720,532/=

611 JOSEH MJOMBA MWANYALO 31/12/1997 257,492/= 15,306/= 100,000/=

612 MWAURA WARUA 31/05/1995

613 JORAM MGANGA MWANJALA

614 GEORGE H. KATSENGA 2/12/1997

615 HEZRON NDOKOLANI KITSAU 2/12/1997

616 GEORGE NZYUKO 2/16/1995

617 MARY AUMA ODONGO

618 PETER SHIMBA CHOLA 31/10/1994 426,260/=

619 MUMBA NZULA MWAGANDI 31/12/1997 874,286/=

620 MUSILI MANGULU 30/09/1995 627,639/=

621 PIUS MANYATA WAHOME 17/02/2006 18,862/= 63,359/= 50,000/=

622 ALBERT MURIITHI 3/12/1997

623 SALIM WAFULE WABWILE

50,000/=

624 DICKSON NZOMO MUTUA MUSYOKI

452,790/= 72,629/= 60,000/=

625 NASHID DICK JAMES

1,209,341/= 268,531/= 100,000/=

626 JAMES T. CHEGE 31/05/1995 555,050/=

267 GERALD M. KARIUKI 27/06/1998 171,616/=

628 FRANCIS M. MBONDO 19/10/1998

629 JULIUS M. KAMAU 18/06/1998

630 MBURU NGANGA

631 GATHIMBA MACHARIA 30/04/1995 1,100,584/=

632 JOSEPH MWANGI KAMAU

633 RICHARD KIPLAGAT A. TEGET 31/10/1998 1,194,467/= 341,476/=

634 KAMBI MWINYI 31/12/1997 637,977/= 90,015/= 100,000/=

635 OMAR MATANO SHABAN 31/12/1997

636 GERALD G. MAINGI 22/04/1998 156,165/= 16,818/=

637 VERONICA W. KAANJA 21/06/2000 1,202,024/= 354,378/=

638 FRANCIS N. GITAU 15/05/1998 1,018,428/= 232,714/= 10,000/=

639 FLORENCEMUTHONI MAINA 15/05/1995

640 JOSEPH ONDIEKI 31/10/2003

10,673,513/= 1,455,266/= 420,000/=

641 EDWARD MBUTHIA WAITHAKA 3/12/1997 1,270,534/=

642 PETER MUTUURA KAMAU 18/02/1998

10,000/=

643 JOSEPHAT MUTUKU MWINZI 31/10/1998 945,665/= 140,705/= 50,000/=

644 GEOFREY MUTUKUMUTISO

645 JOSEPH WACHIRA MUNENE 18/02/1998 509,149/= 78,241/=

646 ALICE K. MUNYAO 3/12/1997

50,000/=

647 JUMA ABDALLAH WAZIRI 31/10/1994

648 JOHN NJOROE 30/06/1995 688,535/=

649 MELECKI W. ODONGO 18/06/1998 1,381,323/= 218,196/= 50,000/=

650 JEMIMMAH WANJIRA

651 FELIX MAINA 18/02/1998

652 OWEN J. MBUGUA 18/06/1998 297,240/= 45,749/= 50,000/=

653 CYRUS MUCHIRI KANYANGO 25/04/2003 1,059,313/= 295,959/= 50,000/=

654 MARY VIOLENTINE ANYANGO 09/06/1998 44,184/= 7,397/= 25,044/=

655 GEOFFREY KINYANJUI MATHEA 18/02/1998 315,632/= 75,531/= 20,000/=

656 LAWRENCE M. MWANGI 18/02/1998

100,000/=

657 IRENEN W. MWANGI 10/12/2014

658 WILFRED NGETI MANAMBO 31/12/1997 171,459/=

659 JOAB ATTE OKADA APRIL 1998

660 SIMON MAKAU 18/06/1998 34,681/= 24,123/= 10,000/=

661 MAURICE APIYO OJOWI 18/03/1998 1,559,967/=

662 KARIKI GACHOKA 19/10/1998 539,796/= 74,408/= 50,000/=

663 SAMWEL M. KARANJA 26/03/1998 1,530,368/= 253,208/= 50,000/=

664 LIVINGSTONE ATIATO ASILU 23/07/1998 94,808/= 7,870/= 10,000/=

665 STEPHEN M. GITONGA 18/06/1998 17,893/= 23,306/=

666 JOSEPH MAINA GITHINJI

113,789/= 15,004/= 10,000/=

667 JONATHAN KENDUIYWA 29/11/1998 1,290,346/= 210,996/=

668 DAVID KIPLAGAT LABOSO 15/07/1999

669 KIBUNUS ARAP TANGUS 22/10/1994

670 SAMWEL R. SUIYON 18/12/1998

671 RICHARD KIPTOO CHERUIYOT 15/07/1999 28,681/= 59,141/=

11,893,363/= 1,528,834/= 535,044/=

672 WILSON CHEPKWONY ARAP RUTO 22/04/1998 1,193,717/= 223,689/= 50,000/=

673 JOEL KIMUTAI SANG 26/03/1998 985,180/= 245,935/= 50,000/=

674 FREDRICK M. SERENGE 17/08/1999 99,830/= 54,357/=

675 FESTUS LUMITI SERENGE 28/03/2006 1,182,213 327,601/= 50,000/=

676 BRIAN JEROME NGOLO 31/12/1997

677 PAUL OMBUI RASUGU 31/10/2003 668,183/= 299,699/= 50,000/=

678 PETER N. GICHANGA 1/01/1998

679 BEN NJOROGE NGUGI 30/09/1995 493,241/=

680 DANIEL THUO WANJOHI 18/06/1998 714,132/= 165,373/= 50,000/=

681 DOMINIC G. THARAMBA

682 SIMON PETER GIKONYO 22/05/1995

683 SIMON KIMANI KAMWEMBU 19/01/1998 188,293/= 21,018/= 50,000/=

684 PAUL SERENGE AMWAYI 31/10/1994 329,043/=

685 JAMES Z. ITHUMBI 31/12/1997 441,097/=

686 ABDALLA M. MWAKIDUDU 2/12/1997 284,416/= 23,373/=

687 ONESMUS M. HEZRON 21/06/2000 502,829/= 94,799/= 50,000/=

688 ZEDI MOHAMMED OMAR 02/12/1997

689 JOHN MBUI NYAGA 31/07/1998 765,402/=

690 HENRY PAULO THIONGO 19/01/1998 283,721/= 36,833/= 10,000/=

691 C. K. MBERIA 10/12/1999

692 JOHN MBUGUA WANYOIKE 31/12/1997 781,888/= 127,544/=

693 FRANCIS KINYANJUI 17/08/1999 737,564/= 17,955/= 100,000/=

694 KAZUNGU KIANGWA 2/12/1997 287,310/= 23,804/=

695 DAVID GITHINJI WAWERU 18/02/1998 969,152/= 175,736/= 50,000/=

696 NICHAEL NZEKI MUTNE 30/06/1998

697 JOSEPH NGUGI NGANGA 31/10/2001 496,972/= 108,856/=

698 JUMA MZEE ALI 28/10/1994 588,871/=

699 HARUNMBUGUA MIINGI 2/12/1997 164,887/= 8,396/=

700 JAMES PAUL OSIDIANA 15/06/1999 815,975/= 152,363/= 60,000/=

701 ISAAC LESEREWAN OLE NAIKUNI

107,392/= 26,185/=

702 WILLY MBURU THUKU

703 LUCY WANJA KARIUKI 15/02/1998 672,102/= 88,524/= 50,000/=

13,753,411/= 2,222,040/= 620,000/=

704 AMOS WAITHAKA NOROGE 31/10/1994 866,748/=

705 SAMWEL MUCHAI NJIRIRI 1/03/1998 1,696,336/=

706 JOSEPH M. MUTIO 21/04/1975 1,271,373/= 248,344/=

707 JOHN RIGUGA MUREHIA

708 GEORGE KURIA GITHINJI 14/07/2000 435,379/= 34,256/= 185/=

709 JOSEH MUSUMBA 31/10/1998 828,417/=

710 TITUS MUTUA NTHUTI 18/02/1998 1,396,304/=

711 HUSSEIN HAMISI KIDIWA 29/03/1996 1,278,998/=

712 ALI SALIM MISUMI 31/12/1997 997,312/=

713 ROBERT MUSYOKA MBITI 31/10/2003

714 AMSTRONG KACHUMBO 15/09/2001 671,504/= 127,283/=

715 PETER WAWERU NDIRANGU 31/03/1999

716 LAWRENCENGILA KAKIU 26/03/1998

717 RASHID M. KUSEMA 15/05/1996

718 THOMAS MAKOKHA 1/04/1998 351,409/=

30,000/=

719 PETER NGOCHI KAMAU

720 EUSEBIAS MAKUNDA CLEO 31/07/1999 145,888/= 48,442/=

721 JOSHUA JUMA MUGA 16/04/1998

722 AHMED MWIRA 31/05/1995

723 NASIR TIMAMI DEC. 1997 293,566/= 22,941/=

724 DUNCAN M. W. KINYEKI 31/10/1998 579,135/= 86,398/= 60,000/=

725 ENOSH KANYARI THIGA 30/06/1998 1,429,787/= 206,603/= 50,000/=

726 STEPHEN MWANGI KAMAU 1/05/1996

727 TITUS OSUMBA OGURO 31/07/1999

728 MORRIS ONYANGO OCHOKA 31/16/1998 889,256/= 108,763/= 10,000/=

729 ELIJAH IRUNGU MUKUHA 31/07/1998 680,864/=

730 TERESIAH MBITH SOO 21/07/1994

731 JOSEPH NDEGWA NDARATHI 31/10/1998 479,655/= 87,717/= 60,000/=

732 DAVID NGUGI KAMAU 30/04/1998

733 TIMOTHY MANZI MUTEMI 6/07/1999 518,896/= 102,277/= 8,130/=

734 ALBERT KIHARA MWITHIGA 18/06/1998

735 JOEL NZIOKA NDAMBUKI 1995

736 SAUL ODIDA OGANGO 31/12/1997 883,149/= 215,127/= 150,000/=

15,693,976/= 1,288,151/= 368,315/=

737 MICHAEL MACHARIA MURAGE 30/04/1998

738 JEREMIAH AYIECHA EKOMBE 31/10/1999 824,267/= 107,784/= 100,000/=

739 JOB KENYASA 31/07/2000

740 DAVID KAMAU WANJOHI 31/05/1995 415,123/=

741 PATRICK NJUGUNA NDUNGU 31/05/1995 283,256/=

742 JAMES KARUE GATHUNGU 31/07/1997 819,707/= 173,674/= 50,000/=

743 ROBERT OTIENO OBONDY 31/12/1997

744 JOSEPH DEDAN OWENYO 31/12/1997 565,727/= 70,000/=

745 SIMON KABAGE KARANJA 28/02/1998 416,640/= 26,868/=

746 MAURICEMAIN BEN 31/07/2000 537,202/=

747 EDWARD KIBET BULUNGU 30/06/1999 390,769/= 68,287/= 100,000/=

748 GIDEON MBUTHIA NGUGI

58,999/= 11,286/= 20,000/=

749 PETER GITHINJI MAINA 30/04/2003 1,152,484/= 301,778/=

750 PETER MUNGAI MUIRURI 31/07/1998 317,282/= 61,592/= 50,000/=

751 FREDRICK KIMEU NZIVO 31/07/2000 1,073,149/= 254,043/= 50,000/=

752 BENSON OLOO MUHASA 31/07/1998

753 CHRISTOPHER KAMTO MWAURA 31/12/1997

754 SAMMY MUTUNGA KUTU 31/03/1996 1,851,878/=

755 JAMES MUTUONGA KINUTHIA 30/09/1998 2,078,953/= 744,989/= 100,000/=

756 BONIFACE NZUKI MUASYA 31/05/1998 933,574/= 222,112/= 50,000/=

757 KISWILI NDUNGA 01/05/1996 1,436,129/=

758 MARTIN NGAIA GAKUYA 16/07/1998 810,262/= 94,574/= 50,000/=

759 HASSAD RASHID MWARANJIRA 31/12/1997 927,168/=

760 CRISPIN NDEGWA 30/06/1995 652,067/=

761 JONES MWANZIA MBITI 31/03/1996 910,930/=

762 JOSEPH MUTHIE KIUGE

763 FREDRICK GITAU NJOROGE 10/03/1996 1,113,491/=

764 MATHEW SASAKA INJEMELA 31/10/1999

60,330/=

765 JONATHAN MUITHYA KILILA 31/03/1998 455,349/= 74,606/= 60,000/=

18,024,406/= 2,271,923/= 630,000/=

766 JOHN IRUNGU GAKUYA 28/02/1998

767 PAUL MARTIN OWUOR 31/07/2000 1,588,206/=

768 HENRY MUASYA MUINDE 31/03/1996

769 STEPHEN MUSYOKA MWAMBI 31/12/1998 485,006/= 134,620/= 100,000/=

770 BENJAMIN BEDAH OMALLA 10/03/2000 4,621,966/= 2,184,835/= 50,000/=

771 PAUL NJOROGE MWANIKI 31/08/1999

772 PETER NDETI GATI 31/10/1994 1,385,506/=

773 EDWARD ISAACK OLAKA 31/12/1997

774 FRANCIS ALAMISI MWAGAMBILI

775 PETER RIUNGA NYAGA 30/04/1998 439,227/= 61,655/=

776 FRANCIS GIKINGU NYAMU 31/11/1998 627,326/= 86,147/= 50,000/=

777 ROBERT ROGERS KABUBA THAIRU

67,149/= 7,683/=

778 PETER KIMANI MUNGAI FEB 1998

10,000/=

779 EDAH NAISIANI NAIKONE

780 JOSEPH NDUNGU GATHARI 31/12/1997

781 SAMUEL KIPKERER NGETICH 31/03/1998 346,134/= 69,829/= 50,000/=

782 JOHN MUCHIRI NDUATI 31/07/1998 325,963/= 67,194/= 50,000/=

783 WILSON NGANGA WAMUHA JUNE 1998

784 MICHAEL MACHARIA MWAI 30/16/1999 814,639/= 143,682/= 60,000/=

785 MWAI MACHARIA 30/04/1995

786 PAUL MWANGI NGATIA 31/07/1999 446,390/= 79,308/= 50,000/=

787 STEPHEN KIKUMU MUTHUSI 30/11/1995 683,581/=

788 KIOKO MANANDI

789 GRACE KAINYU IRERI 31/12/1997

790 RARCISIUS FRANCIS NDUNGU 31/03/1998 60,782/= 29,490/= 10,000/=

791 JOHN KARANJA GAKUNJA 31/05/1998 281,686/= 43,808/= 60,000/=

792 PETER KANINI NJUGUNA 30/06/1998 1,625,082/=

793 ABDALLA KIKOZA OMAR 31/10/1994 879,991/=

794 JORAM KIHARA MUGI 31/12/1997 388,140/= 35,725/=

795 JUDAH KOVO MWANYINDO

15,066,771/= 2,943,976/= 490,000/=

796 DAVID KONANGE MWANGI 08/09/1999

10,000/=

797 PATRICK MUELA MATA 31/12/1997 250,833/= 15,013/=

798 GABRIEL MWANGEMI MACHIA 30/04/1998 963,092/= 185,345/= 50,000/=

799 AQUISIO GITAU

360,333/= 156,775/= 50,000/=

800 MICHAEL OLUOCH 31/10/1999

801 PAKTA SALIM MWARANJIRA 31/12/1997 199,936/= 11,248/=

802 FARID SEIF AHMED 31/07/2000

803 LAWERENCE KIPSEREM SAWE 31/03/1998 1,118,521/= 308,810/=

804 EVANS KAHIRA MUCHIRI 31/10/1994 674,228/=

805 JAMES MWAI KARUGU 30/06/2000 3,258,830/= 1,132,216/= 100,000/=

806 NYENGE NZINZI

807 MOSES MURIUKI NJENGA 31/05/2000 1,626,913/= 563,904/= 100,000/=

808 CLEMENT OGOLA ORINDA 30/04/1995 461,583/=

809 STANLEY KIMANI MWANGI 31/10/1998 580,543/=

810 JOSEPH KAMAI GITAU 31/10/1999 100,000/= 79,112/= 10,000/=

811 ISAAC GITAHI MATU 30/04/2003 2,151,620/= 612,851/=

812 PETER MURU NJENGA 31/01/1999

813 JULIUS KAIBUNGA KIREA 21/11/1998 292,416/=

814 PETER IRUNGU MUIRU

233,641/= 24,984/= 50,000/=

815 DAVID NJOROGE KARANJA 30/04/1998 879,126/= 133,150/= 50,000/=

816 JOHN KANGETHEH NJEHIA 31/03/1998 1,025,304/= 179,095/=

817 P[ATRIKC LUMUMBA MUSONYE 30/06/2000 443,518/= 223,294/= 100,000/=

818 JOSEPH KARANJA GITHINJI 30/04/2003 456,843/= 127,572/= 551/=

819 MAINA STEPHEN KIURI 31/03/1998

820 DANIEL MUKWENZE NZUUKO 05/11/1994

821 CHRISPINUS DOME JOE MAY 2005 1,745,035/=

822 MORRIS ORARO LOET 18/06/1998 1,071,405/= 156,307/= 50,000/=

823 ATHANUS NZAU 07/04/1989 149,632/= 21,491/=

824 JANE NDENGWA MUTHONI 02/12/1997

825 BENARD GATHU MWANIKI 30/04/2006

826 NANCY NGANGA WANJIRU 18/06/1998 1,200,460/= 251,132/=

19,243,862/= 4,182,299/= 570,551/=

827 ROSE MUNINI NUNYAO

1,074,560/= 162,249/=

828 GRACE MUMO 18/02/1998 1,575,820/= 267,246/= 50,000/=

829 JUMA A. RAJAB 15/12/1997 769,427/= 126,692/=

830 STEPHEN KANYINA NDERITU 31/10/1998

831 JOHN IRUNGU MAINA 20/03/1998 512,766/= 97,437/= 50,000/=

832 COSMUS MBUI KISANGI 21/06/2000 185,462/= 50,288/=

833 ONCHOKE MAOBE 18/02/1998 653,984/= 143,348/=

834 MAJOR SAMUEL KARIUKI 14/11/2001

835 FRANCIS NGOTHO 15/09/2001

836 JAMES MURAGURI NDEGE 01/05/1998 325,828/= 31,463/= 50,000/=

837 MUNENE MEJA 30/06/1998 256,152/= 25,867/= 50,000/=

838 CHARLES O. OLUOCH 18/06/1998 657,120/=

839 PATRICK M. MUNGAI 20/09/1995

840 MICHAEL OWN OKELLO 18/06/1998

841 SIMON GICHURA WAMANJI 15/12/2003

842 MUEMBI NDETO DOMNIC 06/02/2015

843 CHALES KIRAGU MBUGUA 21/06/2000 349,676/= 72,120/=

844 BOAZ OMOLO 19/07/1998 1,129,417/= 131,025/=

845 JOSEPH MYUTU MWANGI 18/02/1998 944,994/=

846 NICHOLAS NGANGA 31/05/1998 233,360/= 27,598/=

847 STANLEY NGANGA MUNGAI 18/06/1998 1,358,764/=

50,000/=

848 PETER KIANGA JUNE 1998

849 JEMIMA KIANGA 30/06/1996 1,126,598/=

850 CHARLES WASUNGU 27/07/1998 265,876/=

851 LUCY MUTHONI MATU 31/03/1998

852 NGARI THIGUKU 26/03/1996

853 MATHEWS MINIRE WAIRUGU

854 MAURICE APIYO OJOWI 18/02/1998 1,159,967/= 468,444/=

855 MICHAEL NJOROGE KARIRU 31/05/1995 394,485/=

856 JOSEPH NGOVI MASAKU 31/12/1997 696,408/= 16,757/=

857 BONPHAS MAINA KIAMA

858 DANIEL KISINGU 02/12/1997 353,810/= 32,957/=

859 PETER MWANGI CHOMA 31/03/1998 595,694/= 111,344/= 50,000/=

860 BERNARD KHAMALA OMITO 31/12/1997 680,957/=

15,301,125/= 1,764,835/= 300,000/=

861 PAUL M. MUIA 19/10/1998 684,013/= 113,732/= 100,000/=

862 CLEMENT O. ORINDA 26/04/1995 867,824/= 215,680/=

863 JOHN W. WAITHIRA 23/04/2003 607,360/= 83,160/= 50,000/=

864 JACK AGUTU 18/06/1998 1,509,864/= 313,116/=

865 RUTH NJERI WAIGURU 17/08/1999 658,366/= 152,009/=

866 KULUMBA NZAU 31/10/1994 1,075,314/=

867 PATRICK N. NZIMBI 30/06/1998 417,345/= 50,483/= 100,000/=

868 CECILIA B. MUNYAMBU 21/06/2000 617,862/= 153,826/=

869 ISABELLA W. KAMAU 31/03/2003 3,496,887/= 1,307,009/= 100,000/=

870 DEDAN GICHURU 28/02/2006

871 JOHN M. MUVALI 20/09/1995 535,054/=

872 HERMAN O. FRANCIS 02/12/1997

873 GILBERT K. OHOWA 20/09/1995 606,148/= 87,685/=

874 SOLOMON MUTHEE WACHRA

875 ENOCK OWINO

876 MARY W. HINGA 22/04/1998 586,233/= 48,474/=

877 NJURU GITHAIYA 03/12/1997

878 MOSES AMBANI 27/07/1998 660,275/= 89,009/=

879 ANGELINE OWITI 15/05/1998 748,644/= 91,214/= 65,832/=

880 DAVID G. GATHII 15/07/2003 2,493,362/= 751,938/=

881 HARRY J. AGUTU 19/10/1998 1,041,469/=

882 FREDRICK MWAMUYE 02/12/1997

883 GEORGE NYAWANA 10/05/1995 451,306/=

884 MUSA A. MBITHI 13/02/1998

885 SAMUEL MANGI 18/02/1998 1,175,269/=

886 JOHN M. KIILU 02/06/1995

887 THOMAS K. MUSANGE 17/01/2000 1,856,244/= 628,105/= 100,000/=

888 JOSEPH A. NYAMIRI

889 STEPHEN M. WERU

890 JOSEPH K. GITHINJI 25/04/2003 456,842/= 12,572/= 50,000/=

891 PETER M. MUTURI 22/05/1995

892 JANE W. MUCHAI

470,550/= 49,014/=

893 VITALIS A. ABOKA

894 DAVID W. MUCHERU 18/06/1998 399,224/= 65,612/= 50,000/=

21,415,455/= 4,327,638/= 615,832/=

895 WILSON N. GATHAMBA 21/10/1994

896 EDWARD MAKILA 16/06/2003 2,971,349/= 845,921/=

897 SIMON K. KIRAGU 18/02/1998 558,741/=

898 ANDRE NDUNGU 31/10/1994 551,431/=

899 ROSE W. BULIMU 31/03/2009

900 HENRY J. ATIMA 02/12/1997 210,335/=

901 TITUS KASWAHILI 22/02/2006 3,120,562/= 932,717/= 50,000/=

902 FINNY CHEMTAI 15/05/1998 76,285/= 12,191/= 30,000/=

903 GEORGE KAMARITI 15/05/1995

904 JOAN A. ONYANGO 31/03/2009

905 JAMES N. MWANGI 30/09/1998

906 PHILOMENA N. GATHURU 22/03/1995

907 MUASYA MUTEMI 19/10/1998 518,890/= 85,072/= 50,000/=

908 MESHACK O. OPIYO 31/03/1998 1,227,765/= 279,000/= 50,000/=

909 BISHMARK N. NJUE 18/06/1998 1,065,252/=

910 THOMAS N. MUINDI 02/12/1997 121,259/= 7,405/=

911 PAUL O. OWINO 30/04/2003 421,410/= 130,497/= 50,000/=

912 STEPHEN M. WERU 31/10/1994 560,209/=

913 CYRUS K. GITONGA 19/10/1998 820,831/= 177,045/=

914 MICHAEL A. ASUNA 31/03/1998

915 ABDUL K. MWINYI 31/12/1997

916 PHILIP K. MWANZIA 30/06/1998 693,287/= 117,036/= 50,000/=

917 JOHN N. NYAMU 31/07/1998 288,840/=

50,000/=

918 SIMON M. KAMAU 26/03/1998

919 PETER K. MUCHIRA 30/06/1998

920 CHRISTINE W. KARURU 30/06/1998 736,168/= 83,021/= 50,000/=

921 TIMOTHY H. KAMAU 15/06/1999 154,888/= 46,402/=

922 MWAURA MUGO 01/03/1998 1,351,089/=

923 WILSON N. WAINAINA 31/10/1994 561,249/=

924 SIMON N. KAMIA 15/06/1999 908,621/= 117,316/=

925 PETR W. SANDUKA 15/07/1999

926 NORAH MWABI 22/04/1998 360,833/= 24,365/=

927 KIMWELE KIMANZI 31/10/1994

928 DOMINIC C. WANYAMA 22/04/1998

17,279,294/= 2,857,988/= 380,000/=

929 HUMPHREY R. MBUGUA 09/03/1998 844,375/= 184,660/= 50,000/=

930 JAMES N. MATHEA 03/12/1997 1,806,392/= 381,825/= 50,000/=

931 JOSEPH K. A. KIRUI 15/05/1998 273,305/= 36,760/= 50,000/=

932 JOSEPH O. NYADENGE 01/02/1993

933 JUDAH K. MANYINDO JULY 1998

934 WILSON RUBAI

935 NZIOKA WAMBUA 18/02/1998 1,119,502/= 213,583/= 50,000/=

936 MOSES N. MATHEA 21/08/1998 282,435/= 92,818/= 50,000/=

937 GEORGE M. MUIVA 01/04/1998 1,374,327/= 149,812/= 50,000/=

938 ALEX N. WAINAINA 30/11/2003 1,427,704/=

940 JOMO KASIBWA 27/07/1998

941 JOYCE K. GICHUIYA 27/11/1995

942 BENARD MATHEA 06/03/1996

943 STEPHEN CHEGE

7,128,040/= 1,059,458/= 300,000/=

486,558,724. 58 79,543,483. 52 20,775,144/=

The firm of J. Harrison Kinyanjui & Co. has also filed another schedule in respect of 125 plaintiffs in which they claim for a refund of ksh.9,405,541/=.  Again, the defendant has failed to tender evidence to controvert this claim.  No good reason has been advanced as to why the claim should not be paid. Consequently the plaintiffs listed in the schedule prepared by the firm of J. Harrison Kinyanjui & Co. Advocates should be paid  a sum of ksh.9,405,541/= worked out in the aforesaid schedule as follows:

J. HARRISON KINYANJUI & CO. ADVOCATES - SCHEDULE OF PAYMENT

NO NAME COY

NO DATE OF

TERMINA

TION AMOUNT PAID AMOUNT

TAXED

OFF AMOUNT WITHHELD

1. LAWRENCE KYALO NDUTU 0542 18/9/1998 891,348. 31/= 51,326 50,000/=

2. GORDON OTOLO NGOLO 4053 11/7/1998 742,255/= 138,000/= 50,000/=

3. JAMES NGINGA WAIRIOKO 4022 1998 722,000/= 132,000/= 50,000/=

4. GEORGE NJOROGE NJIGU 1917 APRIL 1998 122,911/= 15,132. 69 50,000/=

5. JAMES SAIYALELE SUIYANGA 1740 18/2/1998 327,770. 36 2,050. 40 50,000/=

6. PHILIP KINYANJUI GITHI 2575 FEB.1998 241,298. 00/= 111,90. 50 50,000/=

7. CHARLES MWANGI GAKOMO 3837 JUNE 1998 1,039,071. 68 278,950. 93 50,000/=

8 MARY PHOLOMENA W. WAMBUGU 6322 DEC. 1997 1,327,738. 63 373,490/= 100,000/=

9. STEPHEN MWANGI WERU 5159 17/10/1994 960,462/= 246,366/= 50,000/=

10 THOMAS O. AMWOMA 3062 FEB. 1998 1,101,150. 10 216,686/= 50,000/=

11 ANDREW MONAYO NYARIBO 2242 FEB. 1998 354,367. 35 60,910. 40 50,000/=

12 DANIEL MUINDUKO MAWATHE 2304 FEB. 1998 785,505. 45 212,796. 88 50,000/=

13 HILARY FRANCIS MBURU 6004 18/2/1998 1,300,283. 22 438,842/= 100,000/=

14 DAVID N. KINUTHIA 6989 1998 960,000/= 248,000/= 100,000/=

15 EDWARD MBUGUA GITAU 7113 18/6/1998 278,702. 12 37,831. 03 50,000/=

16 SIMON MAINA GATHERU 2213 22/7/2000 703,902. 65 134,084/= 50,000/=

17 JULIUS GIKONYO KAMAU 3265 1998 960,000/= 248,000/= 50,000/=

18 JULIUS MWANGI KAMBIA 1643 1998 760,000/= 360,122/= 50,000/=

19 MUIRURI M. KARUGU 510 1995 836,145/= 235,140/= 50,000/=

20 JACOB AGALE OWAK 4610 JUNE 1998 151,710. 11 21,999. 69 100,000/=

21 ALICE NJERI GATHUNGU 0079 1999 96,257. 45 51,151. 27 52,650/=

22 JAMES MATUNDA SAISI 7333 27/7/1998 560,135/= 145,000/= 50,000/=

23 MARIETTA N. MUTISYA 240 MAY 1998 416,894. 33 49,814. 83 50,000/=

24 PETER IRUNGU MWANGI 7236 19/10/1998 171,617. 30 16,702/= 50,000/=

25 JUSTUS KAKUSU MATHEKA 0573 1998 860,135/= 335,000/= 50,000/=

26 NZUKI MUTISYA NDOLO 1946 1998 642,138/= 142,000/= 50,000/=

27 PETER MIRINGU MWAURA 5094 18/2/1998 1,010,135/= 464,135/= 50,000/=

28 JULIUS M. MULWA 4557 17/8/1999 501,116. 85 96,573. 37 100. 000/=

29 MOSES M. MACHIRA 5510 18/2/1998 1,210,135/= 363,135/= 100,000/=

30 JERUSHA NYABOKE 869 15/5/1998 964,135/= 241,140/= 100,000/=

31 MAKIMEI WAIGANJO 882 14/2/1995 590,136/= 135,000/= 50,000/=

32 JAMES MWANGI KABUE 5785 1995 1,110,060/= 265,000/= 50,000/=

33 MOSES OTIENO NDOLO 1369 1998 764,130/= 320,135/= 50,000/=

34 JOHN MUTUA MUTISYA 2643 1998 679,760/= 170,000/= 50,000/=

35 FATUMA GATI CHACHA 4288 1995 464,130/= 112,000/= 50,000/=

36 PETER KAROKI WAIRIUKO 7203 30/6/1999 201,907. 14 28,135. 36 100,000/=

37 DOMINIC NGURE 1159 1998 1,211,552. 28 219,943. 64 50,000/=

38 TIMOTHY LOKI MATHEA 5197 1998 1,34604. 30 360,145/= 100,000/=

39 JOHN KANYI NJOROGE 399 1998 764,135/= 181,132/= 50,000/=

40 THOMAS WAMBUA NGUI 0300 APRIL 1999 1,360,423. 85 456,738. 65 50,000/=

41 CHRISTINE NDUKU 5404 11/11/1995 980,135/= 265,180/= 100,000/=

42 ALOIS KINGORO GICHANA 1725 MARCH 1998 1,814,639. 63 185,329. 15 100,000/=

43 MICHAEL K. MUNANDI 4355 1998 794,135/= 295,180/= 100,000/=

44 ROSE MUENI MUTUKU 4091 2/12/1997 863,17. 62 176,955/= 100,000/=

45 ROHDA MWIKALI NZOMO 5586 1998 1,622,244. 53 289,561/= 100,000/=

46 ANTHONY MWANZIA KILONZO 4120 1998 842,165/= 184,135/= 50,000/=

47 JOSEPH KOKOYO OGWAYO 3087 1999 1,142,564. 25 166,404. 95 100,000/=

48 ANDREW KAMAU GATETE 5864 1997 764,145/= 136,134/= 100,000/=

49 GEORGE WAWERU MWANGI 6023 1995 968,138/= 264,135/ 100,000/=

50 LINUS BIRUNDU OMBUNA 3746 19/10/1998 581,313/= 82,338/= 50,000/=

51 NZIOKA NDUNDA 956 1994 512,796/= 135,640/= 50,000/=

52 DAVID SYANDA KILUNDO 600 2/12/1997 455,777. 28 118,460/= 100,000/=

53 GIDEON OMBURA OUMA 3788 31/10/2003 1,692,667. 90 647,598/= 100,000/=

54 WAMBUA MBELENZI 2806 1998 964,135/= 135,365/= 50,000/=

55 LAWERENCE MWANGI IRERI 1140 1998 571,527. 15 126,574. 18 50,000/=

56 SIMON NDUNGU WANYEKI 1885 1998 215,625. 75 38,083. 75 50,000/=

57 EDWARD MULI 3970 1994 464,135/= 96,135/= 100,000/=

58 PHILIP MUTUKU NYANZI 2326 1994 764,420/= 132,135/= 100,000/=

59 EVELYNE P. A. OYWA 3717 MAY 1999 1,351,944. 70 321,561. 30 50,000/=

60 NYAMBARIGA SILAS ONGIGE 2674 NOV. 1998 1,356,462. 30 318,130/= 50,000/=

61 JOHN KIVULI 7926 DEC. 1997 259,212. 14 9,101/= 100,000/=

62 PETER MWENGI NGUNZE 5642 3/12/1997 960,136/= 238,135/= 100,000/=

63 SUSAN RASMAS CHITECH 7986 2/12/1997 176,428. 09 14,955/= 100,000/=

64 RASHID KANYAU ABDUL 0950 2/12/1997 462,189/= 38,135/= 100,000/=

65 ROBERT M. NJULU 7950 DEC. 1997 188,707. 77 8,398/= 50,000/=

66 DAVID NDALINGA MUTUVI 2846 2/12/1997 834,599. 73 236,145/= 50,000/=

67 JUMA MOHAMMED KIDANGA 7932 2/12/1997 251,938. 77 15,443/= 100,000/=

68 MOHAMMED SAID BWANA IMANI 7807 2/12/1997 812,025. 67 120,587/= 100,000/=

69 GIDEON K. MWENGI 436 2/12/1997 1,385,392/= 252,766/= 100,000/=

70 FRANCIS NGUNZE K 122 2/12/1997 872,150. 13 180,135/= 100,000/=

71 DOROTHY MBEKE SHENYE 6307 1998 764,180/= 234,135/= 50,000/=

72 MAURICE SAKWA 4331 JUNE 1998 251,369. 95 23,243. 34 50,000/=

73 STANLEY G. KENGARA 7132 21/6/2000 864,135/= 231,135/= 50,000/=

74 BARSHORA WACHU BAJARA 1874 2/12/1997 875,748. 25 110,777/= 100,000/=

75 GEORGE S. MSHEDI 7761 1997 1,512,458. 37 289,767/= 100,000/=

76 DZOMBO CHARLES MBURA 0506 1998 820,558. 49 136,626/= 100,000/=

77 JEREMIAH NUNZAA 7964 1997 250,262. 47 15,765/= 100,000/=

78 DOUGLAS HARMTON MALINGI 037 27/6/1995 642,180/= 136,190/= 100,000/=

79 HAMAD JUMA MWANGUPU 7726 1994 812,693. 55

100,000/=

80 LEONARD DUME MBOGA 7709 2/12/1997 1,087,852. 29 157,488/= 100,000/=

81 DAVID MAZERA JOHN 7900 2/12/1997 269,646. 03 18,602/= 100,000/=

82 JOSEPHINE CHEZEZ NDOSHO 441 1996 930,165/= 136,142/= 100,000/=

83 SAIDI AWADHI AWAYU 3400 1996 864,135/= 150,165/= 100,000/=

84 DARIUS KILAMBO 7886 1997 391,871. 34 44,626/= 50,00/=

85 DONAS KIRICHA LOMBO 2915 2/12/1997 981,135/= 194,132/= 100,000/=

86 RACHEL V. W. KEAR 7839 1997 658,888. 82 86,086/= 100,000/=

87 DILTON PASCAL KITATU 0502 1997 579,591/= 69,884/= 100,000/=

88 BONIFACE MUTUKU NDAKA 7868 1997 585,435. 60 77,625/= 100,000/=

89 KIMANI NGERE WAITITU 7759 1997 1,114,740. 17 158,115/= 100,000/=

90 ZIPPORAH DENA FUKWE 0462 1997 764,138/= 197,432/= 100,000/=

91 KENA H. KOMORA 0648 1997 842,138/= 214,134/= 100,000/=

92 CONSTANTIUS MWAKIO MAGHANGA 4360 1997 288,312/= 20,698/= 50,000/=

93 M. ASHODI M. NGIMI KONGONINGA 7901 1997 246,627. 29 13,04/= 50,000/=

94 OCHIENG OMOLLO 5136 1998 1,180,460/= 360,000/= 152,891/=

95 ALPHONCE MWAVULA MWAKIZAI 0585 1995 564,135/= 96,135/= 100,000/=

96 BERNICE WANGECI KINGORI 5658 2002 1,110,000/= 381,142/= 100,000/=

97 GIBSON WANJIHIA M. 3878 1998 764,135/= 184,135/= 50,000/=

98 MWANGI WAMBUGU 1014 1995 465,132/= 96,13/= 50,000/=

99 ANDREW KENGARA MAIGO 724 1995 764,135/= 218,134/= 50,000/=

100 GLORIA AWUOR MANGO 5403 1995 1,164,135/= 348,135/= 100,000/=

101 REUBEN MBIU MWATINGU 696 1998 149,200/= 13,600/= 50,000/=

102 BOOKER AWIMBO OGUTU 2263 1998 663,611. 70 101,600/= 50,000/=

103 JECONIAH ORONJE OWUOR 3227 1998 961,135/= 234,180/= 50,000/=

104 BEATRICE M. KILIO 7762 1997 108,882. 76 39,995/= 100,000/=

105 ASHFORD MA. AYUBU 7945 1997 250,592. 31 18,806/= 100,000/=

106 VICTOR MTUANGUO 3111 1994 641,132/= 160,145/= 100,000/=

107 NARISIS M. MTULA 7851 1997 414,929. 76 35,345/= 100,000/=

108 WILSON NJUKI MAARA 5327 1997 1,231,98. 05 388,650/= 100,000/=

109 CHARLES KIMANI KABUGUA 1266 18/2/1998 1,915,696. 20 325,813. 3. 50,000/=

110 GABRIEL MAINA WAIRE 5119 30/4/1996 1,414,600/= 461,136/= 100,000/=

111 PATRICK NDEGE MUGANE 1694 1995 564,145/= 74,138/= 50,000/=

112 WALLACE SHAKE 4433 1995 484,165/= 65,145/= 100,000/=

113 BENJAMIN MULWA MWANIA 2816 1998 94,030. 70 11,296/= 50,000/=

114 ROBERT M. MWAWUGANGA 3998 1995 961,136/= 192,100/= 100,000/=

115 RAU TSUMA 7738 1994 646,145/= 131,640/= 100,000/=

116 HAMISA MOHAMMED KIDANGA 1591 1995 764,164/= 138,142/= 100,000/=

117 ABRAHAM ORINA 3490 2003 1,107,307. 20 477,747/= 50,000/=

118 ZACKARIA STANLEY WAMBUGU 2380 JUNE 1998 1,129,981. 20 206,202/= 50,000/=

119 PATRICK KAMAU KAGOTHO 5829 2000 1,136,430. 10 189,160/= 100,000/=

120 JERUSHA IRNE SUERO 5954 1997 980,14. 30 190,135/= 100,000/=

121 DAVID MIRERA WACHI 597 1995 964,138/= 165,134/= 50,000/=

122 PAUL MUTHINI IVUSU 3264 1998 934,135/= 180,140/= 50,000/=

123 ISAACK KARANJA WAMBUGU 5489 1999 1,512,269. 75 126,363. 62 100,000/=

124 DAVID MYNYWOKI KITISO 3543 1998 717,707. 90 9,395/= 50,000/=

125 JOHN KURIANGUMI 1910 1998 646,134/= 98,135/= 50,000/=

TOTAL

93,297,344. 44 41,418,429 9,405,541

15)  In the end, I find merit in the plaintiffs’ claim.  Consequently, I issue an order directing the defendant to pay the plaintiffs a sum of ksh.20,775,152 as per the schedule dated 11. 5.2016 filed by Namanda & Co. Advocates and kshs.9,405,541/= as per the schedule dated 23. 10. 2017 and filed by J. Harrison Kinyanjui & Co. Advocates.  The aforesaid amount to attract interest at court rates from the date of judgment until the date of full payment.

16) The third issue which has been identified for determination is whether or not the plaintiffs are entitled to be paid their salaries upto the date of retirement. It is not in dispute that the plaintiffs were on permanent and pensionable terms of employment with the defendant.  It is the submission of the plaintiffs that they had legitimate expectation to work for the defendant until the retirement age of 60 years.  The plaintiffs are of the view that they should be paid their salaries upto the age of 60 years since their employment was guaranteed.  The defendant is of the contrary view that even in a permanent contract, there is no guarantee of employment until retirement.  With respect, I agree with the submissions of the defendant.  Despite the fact that a letter of employment states that the contact of employment is on permanent and pensionable terms, still an employer may terminate the same and the affected employee may file an action for damages for the unlawful dismissal.  It is therefore not correct that the plaintiffs were entitled to payment of salary upto the age of retirement of 60 years.  The prayer is therefore declined.

17) The fourth issue is closely related to the third issue.  It is the question as to whether or not the plaintiffs are entitled to general damages for loss of employment. It is the submission of the defendant that at the time of plaintiffs’ dismissal, the remedy available was damages if a defendant was  liable, was limited to the period of notice applicable under the employment contract.  The defendant was of the submission that since the plaintiffs’ employment was terminated by way of redundancy, they were not entitled to claim damages for loss of employment. It is the submission of the plaintiffs that the entire process they were subjected to was an illegality hence they are entitled to compensation in damages on the basis of a multiplier of their salaries but being capped to 12 months’ gross salary.  The plaintiffs asked this court to award each plaintiff a sum of kshs.10,000,000/= on this head.  Having considered the rival submissions over this claim, I am satisfied that the plaintiffs’ exit from the defendant’s employment cannot be treated as  redundancy.  The defendant simply dismissed the plaintiffs through a process not recognised by the C.B.A and the contracts of employment signed by each plaintiff.  In other words, the plaintiffs were unlawfully dismissed.  The plaintiffs are therefore entitled to receive damages equivalent to the period of notice stated in the contract or the C.B.A.  There is no dispute that the plaintiffs’ employment with the defendant was terminated before the coming into force of the Constitution of Kenya 2010 and the Employment Act, 2007.  In the case of Mary Wakhbubi British Airways PLC (2015) eKLR the Court of Appeal considered the remedies available to an employee dismissed in 2000.  In finding that the remedies  in the Constitution of Kenya 2010, and the Employment Act 2007 did not apply in such a case the court held inter alia:

“All that said, then is to say that this court only has jurisdiction to award the remedies available at the time of the wrongful dismissal or unfair termination, that is, when the cause of action arose.  These are remedies that are provided for under the repealed Employment Act, Cap 226 Laws of Kenya and the repealed Trade Disputes Act, Cap 234 Laws of Kenya.”

In D.P. Bachhetha =vs= Government of the United States of America (2017) eK.L.R the  Court of Appeal held inter alia:

“That an employee whose dismissal was wrongful was only entitled to damages equivalent to the salary he would  have earned during the period of notice applicable in his contract.”

18)  In this case, it is clear from the contract of employment and the memorandum signed between the plaintiffs’  union and the defendant that the defendant was required to pay one month’s salary in lieu of notice. I am of the view that the plaintiffs are each entitled to a sum equivalent to one month’s salary as at the date of termination as damages for loss of employment.  I make the award in favour of the plaintiffs.  The plaintiffs and their advocates file and serve the defendant schedules showing the monthly salary each plaintiff was earning as at the time of termination of employment.  Mention on 6/2/2018 to determine the issue.

19) The final issue to be determined is whether or not the defendant’s calculation of the plaintiff’s terminal benefits were wrong, arbitrary and helped the defendant to withhold huge sums due to the plaintiffs. It is the submission of the defendant that the aforesaid payments were calculated as required under the Regulations of Wages (General) and in accordance with the law governing employees who have been declared redundant.  The plaintiffs are of the view that since they were not consulted, then the defendant’s calculations should be treated as arbitrary.  I have considered the material placed before this court and it is clear to this court that though the defendant did not consult the plaintiffs on the computation of their terminal benefits, the defendant nevertheless gave a schedule showing how the figures were arrived at.  What is clear in my mind is that the defendant proceeded to compute those dues as though the plaintiffs were declared redundant which is not the case here.  In the circumstances, I am unable to make a declaration that the process was wrong or arbitrary.

20)  In the final analysis this court enters judgment in favour of the plaintiffs as follows:

a)It is hereby declared that the decision to cause the plaintiffsto take early retirement was unlawful and in breach of theconstitution and the plaintiffs’ contract of employment.

b)The defendant is hereby ordered to pay each of the plaintiffsdamages for loss of employment a sum equivalent to one (1)month’s salary as at the time of termination of employment.

c)The defendant is ordered to refund to the plaintiffs a sum ofksh.30,180,685/= being the amount withheld in terms of theschedules filed by the firms of advocates of Namada & Co.

Advocates and the firm of J. Harrison Kinyanjui & Co. Advocates tabulated

1. Ksh.20,775,144

2. Ksh. 9,405,541

Total    ksh.30,180,685/=

d)The plaintiffs to be paid by the defendants costs of the suit.

e)The defendant to pay interest on (b), (c ) and (d) above atcourt rates from the date of judgment until the date of fullpayment.

Dated, Signed and Delivered in open court this 24th day of January, 2018.

J. K. SERGON

JUDGE

In the presence of:

....................................................  for the plaintiff

.............................................. for the Respondent