Lesotho Telecommunications Corporation and Another v Nkuebe and Others (CIV/APN/502/97; C of A (CIV) 5/98) [1998] LSCA 2 (1 January 1998)

IN THE HIGH COURT OF LESOTHO HELD AT MASERU IN THE MATTER BETWEEN: C of A (CIV) 5/98 CIV/APN/502/97 LESOTHO TELECOMMUNICATIONS CORPORATION THAMAHANE C. F. D. RASEKILA 1ST APPELLANT 2ND APPELLANT AND MAKHOBOTLELA NKUEBE SELIKANE SELIKANE THABO SEKONYELA MAHOLELA MANDORO MICHAEL RAMOSALLA KOALEPE MAKATSELA FUSI CHOPO RAMOKHETHI DAMANE LEMOHANG FANANA PHAKISO FOSA ANDREAS HANI PAUL HLABANE LESALA HLALELE TŠEPISO HLEHLISI EZEKIEL HLONGWANE TEBOHO HOOHLO MATLALA KAEANE THAPELO KAKA SELAKE KALI RAMAHETLANE KHAKANYO MAKALO KHAKETLA 'MATEBOHO KHALEMA KHASIPE KHASIPE MOHAPI KHAMA NTSANE KHATALA KHECHANE KHECHANE MALEFETSANE KHEO LIMPHO KHETSI SELLO KHIBA MOKHESENG KHOABANE ROSA KHOETE 'MASENTLE KHOLUMO MOITHERI MOHAPI 1ST RESPONDENT 2ND RESPONDENT 3RD RESPONDENT 4TH RESPONDENT 5TH RESPONDENT 6TH RESPONDENT 7TH RESPONDENT 8TH RESPONDENT 9TH RESPONDENT 10TH RESPONDENT 11TH RESPONDENT 12TH RESPONDENT 13TH RESPONDENT 14TH RESPONDENT 15TH RESPONDENT 16TH RESPONDENT 17TH RESPONDENT 18TH RESPONDENT 19TH RESPONDENT 20TH RESPONDENT 21ST RESPONDENT 22ND RESPONDENT 23RD RESPONDENT 24TH RESPONDENT 25TH RESPONDENT 26TH RESPONDENT 27TH RESPONDENT 28TH RESPONDENT 29TH RESPONDENT 30TH RESPONDENT 31ST RESPONDENT 32ND RESPONDENT 33RD RESPONDENT ELIZABETH KHUTLANG NTOILE KOLANE LERATO KOLISANG PHAKISI KOLOBE POELO KOLOBE PAUL KULEHILE TLANTLI LEBALLO 'MAMARALING LEBALLO THABANG LEBOKOLLANE SEKONYELA LEBOPO TELEKO LEBUSA SEEISO LECHE TANKISO LEFULEBE RICHARD LEHLAHA TŠABALIRA LEJAHA LISEMELO LEKHANYA LEPHEANE LEKHETHO LEBABO LEKHOOA RAMOFOLO LEKOATSA GEORGE MOKOENA HUBBERT LELIMO LEPHEANE LEPHEANE HERBERT LEPHEANE RAMOTŠELISI LEPHOTO KARABELO LEROTHOLI ALBERT LESAOANA LEQALA LESEO KHOTHATSO LETELE MOLIBETSANE LETLAKA PHILLIP LETLATSA SEEISO LETSIE TOKA LETSIE PAUL LIETA SEMA LIKOBELO 'MALINEO LIPHOLO RETŠELISITSOE LITLALI THABANG MACHELI VICTOR MAEMA PETER MAFANE LEFA MAFATA TOBATSI MAFELESI 'MASEKOANE MAHAO TŠILONYANE MAHASE THABO MAHLEKE MOHALE MAHLOANE 34TH RESPONDENT 35TH RESPONDENT 36TH RESPONDENT 37TH RESPONDENT 38TH RESPONDENT 39TH RESPONDENT 40TH RESPONDENT 41ST RESPONDENT 42ND RESPONDENT 43RD RESPONDENT 44TH RESPONDENT 45TH RESPONDENT 46TH RESPONDENT 47TH RESPONDENT 48TH RESPONDENT 49TH RESPONDENT 50TH RESPONDENT 51ST RESPONDENT 52ND RESPONDENT 53RD RESPONDENT 54TH RESPONDENT 55TH RESPONDENT 56TH RESPONDENT 57TH RESPONDENT 58TH RESPONDENT 59TH RESPONDENT 60TH RESPONDENT 61ST RESPONDENT 62ND RESPONDENT 63RD RESPONDENT 64TH RESPONDENT 65TH RESPONDENT 66TH RESPONDENT 67TH RESPONDENT 68TH RESPONDENT 69TH RESPONDENT 70TH RESPONDENT 71TH RESPONDENT 72TH RESPONDENT 73TH RESPONDENT 74TH RESPONDENT 75TH RESPONDENT 76TH RESPONDENT 77TH RESPONDENT 78TH RESPONDENT 'MAKOENANE MAHLOMOLA THABO MA1SA SETHO MAJORO SENATLA MAKAE TLALANE MAKAPE REFUOEHAPE MAKHAKHE THERE MAKHALE LIKHANG MAKHOTHE HELEN MAKHOTLA SEBAKE MAKHUTLA TEBOHO MAKOKO TŠOLO MAKOSHOLO 'MALEFU MALEFANE MARTIN MALEKE REENTSENG MALIEHE MAOELA MAOELA PUSETSO MAOELA MAPANYA MAPANYA BOFIHLA MAPHATŠOE MOTLATSI MAPOOANE MBULELO MAQUTU 'MAMPHO MARAISANE KHETHANG MARE KHAUTA MARIE TATUKU 'MASEATILE REFILOE MASENYETSE SEPITLE MASENYETSE 'MALISENTE MASHAPHA MOTEBANG MASHEANE THATO MASITHELA THABO MATAMANE MOOROSI MATELA SEHLOHO MATHAHA 'MABULARA MATOBO SENTLE MATOBAKO THABISO MATSOAI SEUTLOALI MATSOSO THORISO MATSOSO LEBOHANG MBOLE THAPELO MOBE KHOBOSO MOELETSI LAWRENCE MOFOKA MASOABI MOFUBE TSEKO MOHALE NAPO MOHAPI 79TH RESPONDENT 80TH RESPONDENT 81ST RESPONDENT 82ND RESPONDENT 83RD RESPONDENT 84TH RESPONDENT 85TH RESPONDENT 86TH RESPONDENT 87TH RESPONDENT 88TH RESPONDENT 89TH RESPONDENT 90TH RESPONDENT 91ST RESPONDENT 92ND RESPONDENT 93RD RESPONDENT 94TH RESPONDENT 95TH RESPONDENT 96TH RESPONDENT 97TH RESPONDENT 98TH RESPONDENT 99TH RESPONDENT 100TH RESPONDENT 101ST RESPONDENT 102ND RESPONDENT 103RD RESPONDENT 104TH RESPONDENT 105TH RESPONDENT 106TH RESPONDENT 107TH RESPONDENT 108TH RESPONDENT 109TH RESPONDENT 110TH RESPONDENT 111TH RESPONDENT 112TH RESPONDENT 113TH RESPONDENT 114TH RESPONDENT 115TH RESPONDENT 116TH RESPONDENT 117TH RESPONDENT 118TH RESPONDENT 119TH RESPONDENT 120TH RESPONDENT 121ST RESPONDENT 122ND RESPONDENT 123RD RESPONDENT JOBO MOHAPI MAMPHO MOHAPI 'MATHATO MOHASI LIBOKO MOHLALISI THABANG MOIKETSI LEBOHANG MOILOA LEBUSA MOKATI TUPA MOKHALINYANE KOPANO MOKHALOLI NTLOKO MOKHESI SEHLABAKA MOKHOTHU MAFOLE MOKOMA TANKISO MOLAOA KHOBATHA MOLAPO THAPELO MOLAPO MAMOLEBOHENG MOLELEKI SEABATA MOLEPA MOLEF1 MOLETSANE TEBOHO MOLETSANE E. MOLISANE MOLOPI MOLISE TŠELISO MOLISE KHETHANG MOLOISANE ITUMELENG MOMPE TEBOHO MONAHENG LOKISANG MONETHI SELLO MOOROSI ADEL MORIE NTELELE MOROANYANE THETSANE MOROMELLA PHOLO MOSEBO MAPHELETSO MOSENENE TLOKOTSI MOSHASHA MOFEREFERE MOSHEOA THABO MOSHOESHOE LETSITSI MOSIUOA TEBOHO MOSOLA 'MALIMAKATSO MOSOLA NTHUSO MOTHOANA TUMELO MOTHOKHO MANTHA MOTOPI MALEFETSANE MOTSETSERO MOTLATS1 MOTSOANE THAPELO MPASI MOTLATSI MPETE 124TH RESPONDENT 125TH RESPONDENT 126TH RESPONDENT 137TH RESPONDENT 138TH RESPONDENT 139TH RESPONDENT 140TH RESPONDENT 141ST RESPONDENT 144ND RESPONDENT 145TH RESPONDENT 146TH RESPONDENT 147TH RESPONDENT 148TH RESPONDENT 149TH RESPONDENT 150TH RESPONDENT 151ST RESPONDENT 152ND RESPONDENT 153RD RESPONDENT 154TH RESPONDENT 156TH RESPONDENT 157TH RESPONDENT 158TH RESPONDENT 159TH RESPONDENT 160TH RESPONDENT 161ST RESPONDENT 163RD RESPONDENT 164TH RESPONDENT 165TH RESPONDENT 166TH RESPONDENT 167TH RESPONDENT 168TH RESPONDENT 158TH RESPONDENT 169TH RESPONDENT 170TH RESPONDENT 171ST RESPONDENT 172ND RESPONDENT 173RD RESPONDENT 174TH RESPONDENT 175TH RESPONDENT 177TH RESPONDENT 178TH RESPONDENT 179TH RESPONDENT 180TH RESPONDENT 181ST RESPONDENT 182TH RESPONDENT NOOSI MPELA AZAR1EL MPHOFE •MATLALI MPITSO THABANG MPO LIKELELI NALELI EVODIA NKO SHADRACK NKOALE LEPEKOLA NOLOANE TSUKULU NONYANE 'MALISEBO NTEE 'MABATAUNG NTELANE TEMOSO NTOAMPE 'MUSO NTOBO THABANG NTSANE LIAKO NTSEKHE TEBOHO NTSINYI THABANG PANYANE THABO PEEKECHE PALESA PETLANE NICODEMUS PHALIME MOTLATSI PHAROE LETHUSANG PHEKO SEQAO PHENYA MOTSAMAI PHERA KOMETSI PHITSANE RETSELISITSOE PHORI LERATO PITSO BAPHOTHI POFANE KOSI POTSANE JOSEPH QABA KHOABANE QHOBELA KOTSI QHOBOSHEANE MAKHAUTA QOACHELA TEBOHO QOPHE BROWN RAJOELE MATUMISANG RAMABELE LEKHOOANA RAMALIEHE BASIA RAMAOKANE LETEKA RAMASHAMOLE RAPHAEL RAMASHAMOLE JULIUS RAMATABOE MPAI RAMMUSETSI HLOLO RAMORAKANE MAHLOMOLA RAMOTHAMO MPHOBOLE RAMPHOBOLE 183RD APLICANT 184TH RESPONDENT 185TH RESPONDENT 186TH RESPONDENT 187TH RESPONDENT 188TH RESPONDENT 189TH RESPONDENT 190TH RESPONDENT 191ST RESPONDENT 192ND RESPONDENT 193RD RESPONDENT 194TH RESPONDENT 195TH RESPONDENT 196TH RESPONDENT 197TH RESPONDENT 198TH RESPONDENT 199TH RESPONDENT 200TH RESPONDENT 201ST RESPONDENT 202ND RESPONDENT 203RD RESPONDENT 204TH RESPONDENT 205TH RESPONDENT 206TH RESPONDENT 207TH RESPONDENT 208TH RESPONDENT 209TH RESPONDENT 210TH RESPONDENT 211TH RESPONDENT 212TH RESPONDENT 213TH RESPONDENT 214TH RESPONDENT 215TH RESPONDENT 216TH RESPONDENT 217TH RESPONDENT 218TH RESPONDENT 219TH RESPONDENT 220TH RESPONDENT 221ST RESPONDENT 222ND RESPONDENT 223RD RESPONDENT 224TH RESPONDENT 225TH RESPONDENT 226TH RESPONDENT 227TH RESPONDENT 'MATEBOHO RANOOE LEBOHANG RAPILETSA ALFRED RATJOPA TENNYSON SAOANA DAVID SAUDI BAILE SEAKHOA GLADYS SEBATANA THABISO SEHLABAKA LEBOHANG SEKHOAHLA 'MAMOOROSANE SEKOALA AMELIA MOLAPO SECHOCHA SENYANE T. SENYANE LEBOHANG SEPERE MAKHAOLA SEPERE MALEFETSANE SEQHOALA DANIEL SESING REFUOE SETEKA CASWEL SETEMERE 'MAMPHO SETLOBOKO MOLIBELI SHAKE KHETHANG SHALE KHOMOATSANA SHALE KHUPISO SHEA HILDA SHOLU MOJALEFA SUOANE THABANG TAELI ANDRIAS TAKALIMANE MOHAU TAKANA S. THOKOANA THABANG THABA PRESCILLA THAKEDI BOKANG THAMAE MATLERE THAMAE TJOKA THOKO RUSSELS THULO MALATSI TIHELI 'MAMOHALE TJABANE TEMANE TOPO THATO TSALONG HLOMOKA TSEPANE PANYANE TŠEPHE KUBUTU TSIANE MOTLOHELOA TŠIRA LEPHOTO TŠIU 228TH RESPONDENT 229TH RESPONDENT 230TH RESPONDENT 231ST RESPONDENT 232NDRESPONDENT 233RD RESPONDENT 234TH RESPONDENT 235TH RESPONDENT 236TH RESPONDENT 237TH RESPONDENT 238TH RESPONDENT 239TH RESPONDENT 240TH RESPONDENT 241ST RESPONDENT 242ND RESPONDENT 243TH RESPONDENT 244TH RESPONDENT 245TH RESPONDENT 246TH RESPONDENT 247TH RESPONDENT 248TH RESPONDENT 249TH RESPONDENT 250TH RESPONDENT 251ST RESPONDENT 252ND RESPONDENT 253RD RESPONDENT 254TH RESPONDENT 255TH RESPONDENT 256TH RESPONDENT 257TH RESPONDENT 258TH RESPONDENT 259TH RESPONDENT 260TH RESPONDENT 261ST RESPONDENT 262ND RESPONDENT 263RD RESPONDENT 264TH RESPONDENT 265TH RESPONDENT 266TH RESPONDENT 267TH RESPONDENT 268TH RESPONDENT 269TH RESPONDENT 270TH RESPONDENT 271ST RESPONDENT 272ND RESPONDENT TEBOHO TŠOENE NKHAHLE TŠOSANE KOPANG VUMBUKANI BLYTH BAHOLO PUSELETSO BAHOLO ISAAC BELEME JOHN BERENG LEREKO BERENG MOLISE BOHLOKO TANKISO MAEKANE MALOLI MOTHIBELI RAMOFAO MONAKALALI RAMAISA RAMAISA MOTSOELA SEETANE LEFA SEKOATI MOCHEKO ISAAKA MOTLALEPULA MASIA SERUPE MOILOA MAFA HLALELE LEFA MATENA NTJA POSHOLI MAJARA MASOABI MAHASE RABOSHABANE LEMOHANG MOLOFI MASUPHA SEPERE MOKOENIHI CHOBOKOANE THABANG MPUTSOE MOTLATSI NKUNYANE THABO TŠOENE NTHAKO PHATE TUMELO MOQHALI MOLEFI MOLEFI MOLEFI MAILE TANKISO ISAAKA KANATE KOLISANG RANTSOTI MOLOLI LEBONA LEBONA MOLEFI MOTSEKI SEFALI MOKHACHANE HLOLO RAMORAKANE SEPHEKANE MOHAPI ROBERT KOTELO . 273RD RESPONDENT 274TH RESPONDENT 275TH RESPONDENT 276TH RESPONDENT 277TH RESPONDENT 278TH RESPONDENT 279TH RESPONDENT 280TH RESPONDENT 281TH RESPONDENT 282TH RESPONDENT 283TH APLICANT 284TH RESPONDENT 285TH RESPONDENT 286TH RESPONDENT 287ST RESPONDENT 288ND RESPONDENT 289RD RESPONDENT 290TH RESPONDENT 291ST RESPONDENT 292ND RESPONDENT 293RD RESPONDENT 294TH RESPONDENT 295TH RESPONDENT 296TH RESPONDENT 297TH RESPONDENT 298TH RESPONDENT 299TH RESPONDENT 300TH RESPONDENT 301ST RESPONDENT 302ND RESPONDENT 303RD RESPONDENT 304TH RESPONDENT 305TH RESPONDENT 306TH RESPONDENT 307TH RESPONDENT 308TH RESPONDENT 309TH RESPONDENT 310TH RESPONDENT 311TH RESPONDENT 312TH RESPONDENT 313TH RESPONDENT 314TH RESPONDENT