Morop Co Ltd v Committee Kambi Ya Moto Primary School & Laiton Chesang - Administrator of the Estate of Kiplenge Chesang (deceased) [2015] KEELRC 1320 (KLR)

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT OF  KENYA

AT   NAKURU

ELC CASE NO 109  OF  2012

MOROP CO  LTD  ……………………………….…..PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

THE COMMITTEE KAMBI YA MOTO

PRIMARY SCHOOL…………………….......…………..DEFENDANT

LAITON CHESANG -Administrator of the Estate of Kiplenge  Chesang  (deceased) ……..INTERESTED PARTY

RULING

(Application seeking joinder as interested party; applicant stating that he is administrator of the owner hence need to join the proceedings as interested party; no proof of death; no proof that applicant holds the grant of letters of administration; application struck out)

1. The application before me is that dated 23 February 2014 filed by one Laiton Chesang, who seeks to be enjoined to these proceedings as an interested party.

2. The genesis of this suit is a plaint filed on 7 November 2002. The plaintiff is Morop Company Limited, a limited liability company whereas the defendant is the School Committee of Kampi Ya Moto Primary School. The case of the plaintiff is that in the year 1973, it acquired the land parcel Kampi ya Moto/ Kampi ya Moto/Block 1 formerly LR No. 8378/3 which land is approximately 1980 acres. The land was acquired for the shareholders of the plaintiff company. It is averred that in October 2002, the defendant unlawfully entered the plot No. 67, which land measures 20 acres, and started constructing on it. It is the case of the plaintiff that this is trespass. The plaintiff has sought a permanent injunction and an eviction order against the defendant. The defendant filed defence in which the claims of the plaintiff are denied. Further the defendant pleaded that it has been on the suit land for over 35 years.

3. The plot No. 67 seems to have become formally registered as Kampi ya Moto/ Block 1/67. The registered proprietor is one Kiplenge Chesang . Laiton Chesang, who has filed this application, has stated in the supporting affidavit to his application, that he is the legal administrator of the Estate of Kiplenge Chesang, who is said to be deceased. He has stated that the Estate will suffer irreparable loss if it is not enjoined as a party.

4. On the day of the hearing of the application, Mrs. Ndeda appeared for the applicant whereas Ms. Nancy Njoroge held brief for Mr. Olonyi for the plaintiff. Mr. Mbaka of the State Law Office appeared for the defendant. None of the counsels opposed the application.

5. I have considered the application. Although none of the parties has opposed it, I am inclined to disallow it. I have seen from the annexed title that the land parcel Kampi ya Moto/ Block 1/67 is in the name of Kiplenge Chesang. It is said that he is now deceased but there is no Certificate of Death, or other proof, to show that he is deceased. Although the applicant has described himself as administrator of the estate of Kiplenge Chesang, there is not attached any proof that he holds letters of administration. Without these critical documents I regret that I am unable to allow the application. If these documents would have been availed, I would not have had difficulty in allowing the application, for I can see for myself that Kiplenge Chesang, being owner of a land parcel in issue, is clearly an interested party. But for want of proof of death and lack of proof of capacity, I have no option but to strike out this application. A proper one may be filed later.

6. Since the application was not opposed, I make no orders as to costs.

It is so ordered.

Dated, signed and delivered in open court at Nakuru this 18th day of   February 2015.

MUNYAO SILA

JUDGE

ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT NAKURU

In the presence of : -

Ms  Jennifer  Ndeda  for  intended  interested  partly/applicant

N/A   for  M/s   Olonyi  &  Co  for  plaintiff

N/A   for   State Law  office  for defendant

MUNYAO SILA

JUDGE

ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT NAKURU