Ndegwa Gichine v Sicily Warwre Njira [2020] KEHC 5254 (KLR) | Appeal Admission | Esheria

Ndegwa Gichine v Sicily Warwre Njira [2020] KEHC 5254 (KLR)

Full Case Text

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA

AT KERUGOYA

HIGH COURT CIVIL APPEAL NO.  19 OF  2017

NDEGWA GICHINE.........................................................................APPELLANT

VERSUS

SICILY WARWRE NJIRA.............................................................RESPONDENT

RULING

1.  This is an appeal arising from the Judgment and decree in Wanguru Principal Magistrate Court Civil Case No.133 of 2013.  It is now pending Judgment, however, I find that the Judgment in this matter is premature.

2. This appeal was admitted under Section 79 (b) of the Civil Procedure Act, on 7th of May,2018.   On 9th of May, 2018 the Deputy Registrar sent a Notice of Admission of Appeal to the firm of   Wambugu  Kariuki  Associates  Advocates, informing  them  that  the  appeal  had  been  admitted  for  hearing  and  directing  the  advocates   to  prepare a  record  of appeal  and  file  the  same  within  21 days.

3. From the record, there is a letter addressed to the Deputy registrar  by the  said  firm  of  Wambugu  Kariuki  Associates  advocates dated 1st  October, 2018, which  was  received  on  19th  November, 2018,  whose  contents  are  that,   he  had  filed  a  record  of   appeal,   on  25th  of  April, 2018  and served  the counsel  for  the  respondent  on  7th  May, 2018.

4. This appeal was admitted on 7th May, 2018,  which  would mean  that  he  had  filed  the  record  of  appeal  before  the  appeal  was  admitted. However,  upon  perusal  of  the  record,  I  have  not  come  across any  record  of  appeal.  It will  therefore,  not  be  able  to  proceed  to write  the  judgment  without  the  record  of  appeal.

5. If any  record  was  filed, as  stated  in the  letter  by   Wambugu Kariuki  advocates  in  the  letter  mentioned above,  then it  is  not  in the  file.   In the circumstances, the matter will be listed for mention  for  the  counsel  for  the  appellant,  to confirm  whether  the  record  of appeal   was  indeed  filed.  Parties to take a mention date  by  consent.

Dated at Kerugoya this 29th  day of May 2020.

L.W. GITARI

JUDGE